How to compare car insurance quotes

How to calculate your car insurance premiums.

Comparing a lot of car insurance quotes side by side can take a long time.

A car insurance calculator might be a quick shortcut, but unfortunately might not be too much help.

  • Can I use a car insurance calculator? Unfortunately, a car insurance calculator won’t tell you exactly how much it will cost, because there are too many factors involved. You might use a “calculator” provided by insurer, but this is basically just the same thing as getting a quote.
  • Can I use a car insurance estimator? If you think you’re paying too much for car insurance you can estimate your own premiums, based on your circumstances and the average cost of car insurance in Australia.

The most accurate way to compare car insurance is generally to get quotes, and then compare them side by side. The fastest way of doing this might be to simply get quotes individually from each insurer.

After you do, there a few things to watch out for, to make sure you’re comparing them accurately.

Ready to compare car insurance policies?

Details Features
Comprehensive
Comprehensive
Save 24% on your policy if you've been claim free for 3 years.
  • Discounts: No
  • Pay monthly at an extra cost
  • Hire car after theft: Yes - up to $50 a day
  • Choice of repairer: No
  • Roadside assistance: No
Get Quote More info
Comprehensive
Comprehensive
Save up to 15% when you buy online.
  • Discounts: Buy online and save 15%
  • Pay monthly at an extra cost
  • Hire car after theft: Yes - up to $1,000 (limit 14 days)
  • Choice of repairer: Yes
  • Roadside assistance: Optional
Get Quote More info
Comprehensive
Comprehensive
Buy online and save up to 10%. Price-beat guarantee for drivers aged over 25.
  • Discounts: Buy online and save up to 10%
  • Pay monthly at no extra cost
  • Hire car after theft: Yes - up to $70 a day for up to 14 days
  • Choice of repairer: No
  • Roadside assistance: Optional
Get Quote More info
Comprehensive
Comprehensive
Complete a quote but don't end up switching? You'll still get 100 YouiDollars.
  • Discounts: Chance for 100 YouiDollars
  • Pay monthly at an extra cost
  • Hire car after theft: Yes - Reasonable costs for 14 days
  • Choice of repairer: Yes
  • Roadside assistance: Yes
Get Quote More info
Comprehensive
Comprehensive
Buy online and save up to 10% on your policy.
  • Discounts: Save up to 10% when you buy online
  • Pay monthly at no extra cost
  • Hire car after theft: Yes - up to $70 a day for 14 days
  • Choice of repairer: No
  • Roadside assistance: Optional
Get Quote More info
Price Saver (Comprehensive)
Price Saver (Comprehensive)
New customers can receive up to 10,000 Velocity Frequent Flyer points. Ends 28 Feb 2018.
  • Discounts: Buy online and save 15%
  • Pay monthly at an extra cost
  • Hire car after theft: Yes - up to $1,000 (limit 14 days)
  • Choice of repairer: Yes
  • Roadside assistance: Optional
Get Quote More info
Comprehensive
Comprehensive
Transforms your driving so it's 100% carbon neutral.
  • Discounts: No
  • Pay monthly at no extra cost
  • Hire car after theft: Yes - up to $70 a day for up to 14 days
  • Choice of repairer: No
  • Roadside assistance: No
Get Quote More info
Comprehensive
Comprehensive
Save up to 10% when you buy online.
  • Discounts: Buy online and save up to 10%
  • Pay monthly at no extra cost
  • Hire car after theft: Yes - up to $100 a day for up to 30 days
  • Choice of repairer: Yes
  • Roadside assistance: No
Get Quote More info
Comprehensive - Elegant Cover
Comprehensive - Elegant Cover
Save up to 20% when you purchase online.
  • Discounts: Save up to 20% when you purchase online
  • Pay monthly at an extra cost
  • Hire car after theft: Yes - up to $60 a day for up to 14 days
  • Choice of repairer: No
  • Roadside assistance: Optional
Get Quote More info

How to compare car insurance quotes

Ever wondered why quotes for similar cover might be very different from one another? You might not be comparing equivalent prices.

  • Does the quote include discounts? The quote you’re given will often be the lowest possible price. For example, sometimes it might include a hefty 25% car insurance discount for buying online, while another insurer might offer the same discount, but not include it in the quoted price.
  • How much information did you provide before getting a quote? If you simply provided your car make and model for a quote, but haven’t yet given your age, address and other information, the quote might not be your “final price.” Generally, the more information you’ve provided, the more accurate your quote will be.
  • Is the cover equivalent? Even two comprehensive policies might be very different, which can lead to significant price differences.
  • Do you need a special type of car insurance? Driving for business, carrying passengers for pay, adding a lay-up period and other variations can all change premiums a lot.

Steps to follow when comparing car insurance quotes

The first step is to work out whether you want or need special cover, to make sure you’re comparing the right policies and won’t be paying too much for car insurance.

After you get a quote:

  1. Consider how much information you’ve provided for an understanding of how accurate the quote is. If you know the factors that affect the cost of car insurance you can guess whether it might be too high or too low.
  2. Consider whether the quote also includes any discounts, or other factors that may affect the final price.
  3. Look at the different cover elements side by side, and see whether that accounts for the price difference.
  4. Rule out the prices that are too high, or the cover that doesn’t work for you, and create a shortlist.
  5. Get detailed quotes from your shortlist of providers and take out cover online for more discounts.

The wide range of factors that affects car insurance prices means a quote might not be finalised or accurate until you provide all the details and choose your cover. These variations mean a car insurance calculator will typically not be very accurate.

Variations to consider

Until you decide on the following, your car insurance costs might change.

  • What type of car insurance you’re taking out, and whether it’s comprehensive, third party only, or third party with fire and theft cover.
  • Agreed value or market value
  • Whether you’ll be getting any optional extras
  • Whether you’re entitled to any multi-policy discounts, online discounts or other savings
  • If you can pay less thanks to car security systems, or because you park it in a secure garage
  • If you’ve provided your age, postcode and make and model of car
  • Whether or not you’ve specified any applicable business use
  • Whether or not you’ll be restricting or nominating drivers, where applicable

When you compare car insurance quotes, one insurer might draw you in with the cheapest prices, only for them to go up as you provide more information and make more cover decisions.

Another might do it the other way around, and start with a higher quote that gets cheaper as you make more cover decisions.

There probably isn’t a quick and accurate car insurance calculator that can help you with all the calculations you need to do. So instead it might be worth taking your time, shopping around carefully and getting multiple detailed quotes, to make sure you’re comparing equivalent cover types and looking at accurate prices.
Picture: Shutterstock


Get the latest car insurance news

Andrew Munro

Andrew writes for finder.com, comparing products, writing guides and looking for new ways to help people make smart decisions. He's a fan of insurance, business news and cryptocurrency.

Was this content helpful to you? No  Yes

Related Posts

Ask an Expert

You are about to post a question on finder.com.au:

  • Do not enter personal information (eg. surname, phone number, bank details) as your question will be made public
  • finder.com.au is a financial comparison and information service, not a bank or product provider
  • We cannot provide you with personal advice or recommendations
  • Your answer might already be waiting – check previous questions below to see if yours has already been asked

Finder only provides general advice and factual information, so consider your own circumstances, read the PDS or seek advice before you decide to act on our content. By submitting a question, you're accepting our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.

2 Responses

  1. Default Gravatar
    ShannonOctober 11, 2017

    My son who is 19 and on his red p’s has had his license suspended for 3 months for 10km over the limit in a 50km zone and is about to get his license reinstated and his current insurer has lapsed.
    He is finding it very difficult to get third party property insurance from any insurer, do you know of any providers who could help or who specialises in high risk car insurance

    • Staff
      JoanneOctober 11, 2017Staff

      Hi Shannon,

      Thanks for reaching out.
      This page will explain details about a high risk car insurance and how one is classified as a high risk driver. On the same page you can enter your zip code for you to receive quotes.
      In addition to that, you may also want to visit this helpful page to check available options for those who just got their P’s.

      Cheers,
      Joanne

Ask a question
Go to site