Both Budget Direct and AAMI are relatively cheap car insurers though our research suggests Budget Direct is slightly cheaper on average. If you're looking for a little more on benefits such as a hire car after theft, AAMI may be more suited to your needs.
We've compared the comprehensive car insurance policies on offer from Budget Direct and AAMI car insurance. See the key differences between the two.
Budget Direct Comprehensive |
AAMI Comprehensive Car Insurance |
|
|---|---|---|
| Underwriter | Auto & General Insurance Company Ltd | AAI Limited |
| Accidental Damage | ||
| Damage to other people's car |
|
|
| Bonuses | 15% online discount | $50 online discount |
| Roadside assistance | Optional | Optional |
| Agreed or market value |
Agreed or Market |
Agreed or Market |
| Choice of repairer | Optional | |
| Legal liability | Yes - $20,000,000 | Yes - $20,000,000 |
| Fire and theft | ||
| Storm | ||
| Flood | ||
| Hire car after theft |
Up to $1,000 - Up to 14 days |
Reasonable costs - Up to 21 days |
| Hire car after no fault accident |
Optional Up to $75 per day - Up to 14 days |
Optional Up to $90 per day |
| Hire car after at fault accident |
Up to $75 per day |
Limit not disclosed |
| Emergency repairs |
Up to $500 |
Up to $1,000 |
| Emergency travel and accommodation costs |
Up to $1,000 - Up to $200 per day |
Up to $1,000 |
| New car replacement |
If your car is written off in the first 2 years or is under 40,000kms |
If your car is written off or stolen in the first 2 years |
| Personal effects/property |
Up to $500 |
Up to $1,000 |
| Locks and keys replacement |
Up to $1,000 |
|
| Towing | ||
| Trailer cover |
Up to $1,000 |
Up to $1,000 |
| Important | Limits, exclusions and terms and conditions apply. Read the Product Disclosure Statement. | Limits, exclusions and terms and conditions apply. Read the Product Disclosure Statement. |
| Get quote | More info |
As part of our 2024 Finder car insurance awards, we collected over 1,800 car insurance quotes from 30 car insurance providers, using a range of driver profiles across different states, ages and genders. Below is a breakdown of that research for Budget Direct and AAMI.
On average, Budget Direct typically offers cheaper car insurance than AAMI. However, it's important to keep in mind that price may not be the only factor in your search for the best car insurance.
| Provider | NSW | QLD | SA | TAS | VIC | WA | Aus average |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Budget Direct | $1,148 | $941 | $978 | $829 | $1,180 | $880 | $992 |
| AAMI | $1,884 | $1,106 | $1,015 | $985 | $1,318 | $1,002 | $1,218 |
These quotes are based on a fictional driver profile and your own quote will differ based on your personal circumstances. This should be used as a guide only.
About our car insurance methodology
| Response | |
|---|---|
| Yes | 67.59% |
| No | 27.34% |
| I don't have own a car/car insurance | 5.07% |
Budget Direct offers 4 types of car insurance:
AAMI offers 2 types of car insurance:
AAMI's third party property damage policy can have fire & theft car insurance added to it.
Both AAMI & Budget Direct were tied in the Finder customer satisfaction awards. Both scored 4.32/5. We asked over 5,700 Australians in total. AAMI car insurance has more negative reviews on popular review websites than Budget Direct.
Using data from the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA), we can see how many motor insurance complaints the underwriters from AAMI (AAI) and Budget Direct (Auto & General) have received and resolved.
While AAI has received more complaints, it's important to note that it has a larger market share and seems to have resolved those complaints at a higher rate than Auto & General.
| Underwriter | Complaints received | Complaints resolved at registration & referral | Referral resolution rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| AAI | 2231 | 1370 | 61.43% |
| Auto & General | 1431 | 723 | 50.56% |
You can claim online, over the phone or via chat with Budget Direct.
With AAMI, claims can be made via the AAMI My Account. Once you've filled out the form, an AAMI claims consultant should get in touch with you.
Both insurers offer agreed or market value options when you take out cover. Market value pays you the market value of your car at the time it's written off. Agreed value pays you the amount you agree with your insurer when you take out a policy.
Budget Direct is typically a little cheaper than AAMI and has more positive customer reviews online. They're pretty similar in terms of their level of cover, though AAMI gives you a little more for your money with some benefits such as a hire car after theft and a no fault accident. It's also a very popular insurer with a good network of repairers. In general though, both insurers offer very similar levels of cover.
Gary Ross Hunter
Insurance and innovations editor
Learn the factors that may cause you to be considered a high-risk driver and whether you might be eligible for cover.
What you need to know about getting a multi-policy discount with your car insurance.
Only available in WA, RAC car insurance offers some strong benefits and its premiums are about average for the state.
Your questions about no claim bonuses answered, including whether it's worth paying to protect your bonus, the NCD rating, and what you can claim.
Find out what car insurance options are available for rideshare drivers, including Ubers.
Your guide to car insurance when you've been convicted of drink driving.
Find out what short term car insurance options are available in Australia.
Find affordable and comprehensive car insurance for P-platers with this handy guide.
Compare Australia Post car insurance policies and get the right cover.
Explore our analysis and see how you can find the best car insurance for your needs.
