Is it better to lease or buy a car?
Not sure if you should buy or lease a car in Australia? Compare your options here.
Key takeaways
- Leasing a car can be cheaper in the short-term and you can upgrade the car every few years, but you won't own anything.
- Buying a car gives means you own the asset and you can sell it later if you need to. You pay more upfront but probably save in the long run.
- Before deciding between leasing or buying, factor in your total costs including fees, taxes and depreciation.
"To lease a car, or to buy a car, that is the question."
If you can't decide between buying or leasing a car, then our guide will help you.
What is the difference between leasing and buying?
The key difference between buying and leasing a car is ownership of the vehicle, but this could be a positive or negative depending on your situation.
In general, leasing will offer more flexibility and likely cost less. Buying a car will likely to be more expensive, but could give you greater stability and the benefits of ownership.
Leasing a car gives you access to a vehicle for an agreed period, which can be for personal or business use, or a combination of the two. You will generally make regular payments over the course of the lease and may have the option to buy the car, or starting leasing a new vehicle, at the end of the lease term.
Buying a car involves you purchasing a vehicle so that you own the vehicle outright. You can either make your purchase using a car loan, which can be paid off in a period of up to seven years, or by buying the vehicle using your own savings. You are then free to use the vehicle as you wish, as well as sell it.
Buying vs leasing: Pros and cons
| Pros | Cons | |
|---|---|---|
| Leasing |
|
|
| Buying |
|
|
What financing options are available for cars?
- Secured personal loan. A personal loan that is secured works by you using the car as a guarantee in order to finance it. This is less of a risk for the lender as they can sell the car should you default on the loan. These loans generally have lower rates and fees and are offered as a fixed or variable rate option.
- Unsecured personal loan. An unsecured personal loan can not only be used to finance a vehicle, but can also be used for any other purchase you wish to make. These loans are flexible but they usually come with higher fees and rates because it is a risk to the lender.
- Dealer finance. If you purchase a car from a dealership then they will most likely have a financing option they are able to offer you. It's best to do your research before you sign up as dealer financing usually comes with inflated rates and high fees. Dealer finance usually comes with a balloon payment at the end that is designed to lower your ongoing repayments.
- Novated lease. A novated lease is basically a lease agreement between you, your employer and the lease provider. Some of your lease obligations are transferred to your employer and as such your car is treated like a company car for tax purposes. This type of lease can save you money by allowing you to access benefits such as GST discounts, income tax savings and savings on the cost of running the car.
Compare your leasing and car loan options
Compare other products
We currently don't have that product, but here are others to consider:
How we picked theseFinder Score for car loans
To make comparing car loans even easier we came up with the Finder Score. Interest rates, fees and features across 200+ car loan products and 100+ lenders are all weighted and scaled to produce a score out of 10. The higher the score, the more competitive the product.
Frequently asked questions about leasing or buying a car
Sources
More resources on Finder
Ask a question
29 Responses
More guides on Finder
-
Green Car Loans Australia
Some lenders offer a better deal if you get a loan for an eco-friendly car. See how they work and compare car loans here.
-
Car loans for pensioners
On a pension but need a new car? There are still many choices if you know where to look.
-
Compare car loans for classic cars
Want to buy a classic car but don't have the ready money? There are still financing options available for classic vehicles. Find out what loans you have to choose one and which one will work best for you.
-
Tesla Superchargers Map: Where you can charge in Australia
Find out the extent of Australia's Tesla Supercharger network with our complete map of every charging station.
-
IMB car loans
Find out how to take advantage of competitive rates, no monthly fees and an easy application all while getting the finance you need with IMB loan options.
-
People’s Choice Credit Union secured and car loans
People’s Choice offers competitive loans with pre-approval, rate discounts and other features to help put you behind the wheel of a new or used vehicle.
-
Should I refinance or pay my novated lease balloon payment?
If you've come to the end of your novated lease and you are left with a balloon payment, you might be wondering whether to refinance that into a personal loan or take on another novated lease.
-
First Option Bank Car Loans
Lock in a competitive rate for as long as five years with First option Bank – you can finance both new and used car loans.
-
BankSA Car Loans Comparison
BankSA offers a range of loans for your next car. If you're looking to finance a new or used car you can consider a secured or unsecured personal loan from BankSA, both with competitive rates. Compare and apply today.
-
Gateway Bank Car Loans
If you're in the market for a range of loans, Gateway Bank might have an offering worth considering. You can use your car as security and get a lower rate with both new and used vehicles, so compare and apply today.
If I have salary sacrificed too much for my car, do I get the money paid back to, ie is it pit back into my salary and taxed accordingly?
Thanks
Hi Rooster,
You’ll need to look at the terms of the agreement, but generally, if you do fewer miles than is budgeted or you have salary sacrificed too much, the money should be paid back to you. You’ll need to contact the company administering the lease.
Hope this helps,
Elizabeth
I recently started a sales job (commission only, no salary). My 11 year old car died just a few days ago (had only done 77,000km in 11 years). So, I am in the market for a new one (I’m borrowing a car meanwhile). I have a few options:
1. buy a new car outright (huge cash outlay from my savings. I want to get my lifelong dream car… a mini convertible)
2. Wait and buy a demo mini
3. Buy a used mini but risk costly repairs
4. lease the mini
5. approach my employer to contribute to a lease but considering I’m not paid a salary I don’t know that this is possible?
Any suggestions?
Thank you!
Hi MiniMe,
I can’t advise you which will be the best option for you as it will really depend on your own individual needs and financial situation. However, I can provide you with some general information and guides that will help.
Using your savings is a great way to purchase a car and won’t leave you in debt except you won’t have a buffer to use for anything else, and you should also consider if you’ll need that money for other reasons. In terms of demonstrator vehicles, this is also a great way to save. You can read our demo car buying guide to learn how much you can save.
A used car can also be a good chance to grab a bargain as long as you inspect the vehicle thoroughly. We’ve written a used car checking guide that you can take a look at to familiarise yourself.
Leasing the mini may also be an option if that works for your needs and lifestyle, but just keep in mind you won’t be owning an asset. In terms of a novated lease, it will be up to your employee whether they offer this option to you. If they do, this is an easy method for you to pay for a vehicle. Please read more about novated lease through our website.
I hope all of this information will be of use.
Thanks,
Elizabeth
Thanks so much Elizabeth. Much appreciated!
If I get a novated lease on my car will I need to pay FBT?
Hi Dora,
It depends which method you choose when taking out a novated lease. There are two methods you can opt for when taking out a novated lease: the Fringe Benefits Tax method or the Employee Contribution Method. You can see an outline of those two options so you can choose the best one for your situation.
Before applying, please ensure that you meet all the eligibility criteria and read through the details of the needed requirements as well as the relevant Product Disclosure Statements/Terms and Conditions when comparing your options before making a decision on whether it is right for you.
Hope this helps,
Elizabeth
My current car is under novated lease, the lease expires in Feb 2015. There is a balloon amount which I need to pay to acquire the car.
I want to keep the car for another 2 years, can you help me with a tool or calculator to decide if i should refinance or go in for another lease term?
Hi Tarun,
You can use our novated lease calculator and our personal loan calculator to calculate your costs and find out which option will cost you more in the long run.
Please ensure to read through the relevant product disclosure statement and terms and conditions of your loan to ensure that you got everything covered on your loan.
I hope this will help.
Thanks,
Elizabeth
This information has been really useful, including the section on car loan rates through RACQ and the banks. Thank you !!!
Hi Nat,
Thanks for the feedback we are glad that you found the content so useful.
Regards
Jodie