Which online share trading platform is the best choice when you need to buy and sell international shares: nabtrade or CommSec?
When it comes to the competitive, online share trading industry, both nabtrade and CommSec are market leading brokers. We know how difficult it can be to find Australian brokers who offer affordable and convenient ways to trade international shares, so have published this guide to help you find the account that works best for you.
Keep reading and you'll discover that we've compared the account features of both nabtrade and CommSec. If you want more specific details on either account, you can always click through to the our individual broker review pages.
To help make this particular comparison easier however, we've run a case study on an Australian named Joe, who wants to buy $1,000 of US shares on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE).
Joe’s Trading Dilemma
Joe, 46, is a school teacher from Sydney’s northwest. Having recently paid off his mortgage, Joe has spent the past few months assessing a range of investment opportunities and has decided he’d like to invest in the share market. As well as shares in several blue-chip companies listed on the Australian Securities Exchange (ASX), Joe would like to invest some of his money in shares in US companies listed on the NYSE.
But Joe is unsure which share trading platform he should use to place the trades. Joe has bank accounts with both NAB and CommBank, so he is willing to consider opening a trading account with either of the banks’ respective trading platforms, nabtrade and CommSec.
To decide which platform offers the best solution for his trading needs, Joe decides to look at a specific trade he plans to place and see whether CommSec or nabtrade offers the best value for money. He compares the cost of buying $1,000 of shares in pharmaceutical giant Pfizer to see how the two platforms stack up against each other.
|Pfizer share price||USD$36.78||USD$36.78|
|Total cost of share parcel (27 shares)||USD$993.06||USD$993.06|
|Foreign currency conversion fee||AUD$6.50 (0.65% of trade value*)||N/A|
|Total fees||AUD$21.45 (approx USD$16.11)||USD$19.95|
*Nabtrade expresses its foreign currency conversion fee as a spread ranging from 0.50% to 0.80% of trade value.
In dollar terms, this ranges from AUD$4.97 to AUD$7.94 in the above case study. The actual amount charged to your nabtrade account depends on the time of the transaction. For purposes of this case study, we have used the midpoint in the range.
Rates accurate at 27 June 2016.
As you can see, the comparison is far from straightforward due to a couple of key factors. The first cost that needs to be considered is the brokerage fee - CommSec’s fee is the higher of the two and is also charged in US Dollars instead of Australian Dollars.
However, nabtrade also charges a foreign exchange conversion fee of between 0.50% and 0.80% of the transaction value. So not only will the cost of your transaction vary depending on the percentage amount of the fee, but it will also depend on the value of your transaction and the exchange rate market at the time.
Taking current exchange rates into account at the time of writing (1 AUD = 0.75 USD - 26/07/2016), in the above example nabtrade offers the most cost-effective solution. However, as you will see in the case study below, that may not always be the case with larger transactions.
Case Study 2: Joe increases his investment
After enjoying some early success trading on the ASX, Joe now has a significantly larger amount of capital to invest. He now wants to buy $5,000 worth of Pfizer shares on the NYSE, so he once again compares the cost of placing the trade with nabtrade or CommSec.
|Pfizer share price||USD$36.78||USD$36.78|
|Total cost of share parcel (136 shares)||USD$5002.08||USD$5002.08|
|Brokerage fee||AUD$6.50 (0.65% of trade value*)||USD$29.95|
|Foreign currency conversion fee||AUD$32.50 (0.65% of trade value*)||N/A|
|Total fees||AUD$39 (USD$29.38)||USD$29.95|
In this example, CommSec represents the more affordable option for two reasons:
- nabtrade’s brokerage fee for trades over AUD$5,000 (and below $20,000) rises to AUD $19.95. CommSec’s fee for trades over USD$5,000 (and below $10,000) rises to USD$29.95.
- As this is a much larger transaction than the first case study, the foreign currency conversion fee charged by nabtrade rises substantially.
So if you're wondering whether nabtrade or CommSec is the more affordable option when you need to trade shares on a US stock exchange, the answer is that it depends on the size of your transaction. For smaller trades, nabtrade will usually be the more cost-effective option, but if you need to place a large trade than CommSec will probably come out on top.
Foreign exchange conversion fees
You may have noticed in the above examples that nabtrade charges a foreign exchange conversion fee and CommSec does not. The reason for this discrepancy is quite simple.
Whenever you execute an international share trade with nabtrade, a foreign exchange transaction occurs - i.e., you need to convert the Australian Dollars in your trading account into US Dollars in order to buy shares on a US stock exchange. nabtrade charges a foreign exchange conversion spread of between 0.50% to 0.80% of the value of your trade.
But if you have a CommSec share trading account, you can take advantage of CommSec's partnership with Pershing LLC, a subsidiary of the Bank of New York Mellon. Pershing automatically opens a US account for all CommSec International Securities Trading clients, allowing you to settle trades through this US account and avoid any foreign exchange fees when you buy US shares.
It's also worth pointing out that the brokerage fees charged by nabtrade and CommSec vary depending on the size of your international trade. This can obviously have a huge bearing on the total cost of your transaction, so it's worth examining the tiered fee structure of each provider when comparing nabtrade vs CommSec.
Nabtrade brokerage fees for international shares
All figures in AUD
|Trade type||Transaction size||Brokerage|
|Online trading||Up to and including $5,000||$14.95|
|$5,000.01 - $20,000||$19.95|
|Over $20,000||0.11% of trade value|
|Over the phone||All||$59.95 or 0.55% of trade value (whichever is greater)|
CommSec brokerage fees for international shares
All figures in USD
|USA||$19.95 for trades up to $5,000$29.95 for trades up to $10,0000.31% of transaction value for trades above $10,000|
|Canada||$65 or 0.75% of transaction value (whichever is greater) + 0.15% execution fee|
|Asia Pacific||$39.95 or 0.40% of transaction value (whichever is greater)|
|Europe and Middle East||$39.95 or 0.40% of transaction value (whichever is greater)|
Other factors to consider when comparing online share trading platforms
Although the fees that apply to international share trading are undoubtedly an important factor when comparing share trading platforms, there are several other features to consider before you choose a platform. These include:
- Market data. How can you access market data through each platform? Are prices delayed or can you access live or dynamic data? Are there any additional costs attached?
- Research and analysis. Compare the analysis and insights you can access through the platform to help you make better trading decisions. This could include market news, in-depth analysis of individual stocks and buy and sell recommendations.
- Ongoing fees. Some share trading platforms trade an ongoing monthly or annual membership free, others are offered free of charge and fees only apply when you place a trade.
- Accessible markets. Compare the international stock exchanges and shares you can access through each trading platform. Can you also access other international investments, for example exchange traded funds (ETFs) or exchange traded options (ETOs)?
- Trading options. Check to see what sort of flexible trading options are available to help you take advantage of changing market conditions, for example stop loss orders and limit orders.
- Customer support. If you ever have a question about a trade or need assistance, how will you be able to access customer support? Does the provider have a good reputation for responding to enquiries quickly and helpfully?
Compare International share trading accounts
CommSec and nabtrade are both well worth considering when you need to trade shares on international markets. Check out each of our broker reviews, while comparing the fee structure and features of the two accounts.
If neither CommSec or nabtrade look right for you, why not compare some of the other brokers in the table below.