Damaging report into State of Origin eligibility fingers Queensland. Queensland is twice as dependent on non-Queenslanders than NSW.
Since the Super League War
- Since 1995, on average 27.12% of the QLD team were not born in QLD (QLD has one 61% of the series with a result in this time)
- Since 1995, on average 6.34% of the NSW team were not born in NSW (NSW has won 39% of the series with a result in this time)
- NSW has not fielded a player born in QLD since 1995
- QLD has fielded a NSW player in its team every year since 1991
- Brad Thorn is the biggest loser in State of Origin series, winning only 9.09% of his 11 games (data restricted to players of 10 games or more)
- Ben Kennedy is the biggest winner in State of Origin series, winning 76.92% of his 13 games (data restricted to players of 10 games or more)
- Greg Inglis has played the most games against his rival state at 24
What's trending right now with State of Origin?
Mate against mate, state against state – or so the claim goes – but is it really true?
With every passing year the concept dilutes as eligibility blurs. What are the actual facts? Has one team been bending the truth more than another? We crunched the data and have the answer, it is a definitive 'yes!'
Since the first State of Origin game on July 8, 1980, 179 players have represented Queensland, and 257 have turned out for NSW. Together they have contributed to 102 games across 33 full series and three standalone showcases. Queensland has won 18 of those series, New South Wales 13, and two were drawn. In total, Queensland has won 54 games, NSW 46 and two were drawn.
The series is famous for its equilibrium, with the teams so evenly matched over such a long period that games have literally been decided on one dropped ball, missed tackle or dodgy call - the line is that thin. But how often has the line between victory and failure been torn by players representing a state under false pretences? What is the true impact these players have had on the overall State of Origin legacy, and the results of individual games and series themselves? We found out.
Yes, let’s start at the end. Below you will find all the data and the data shows that Queensland has significantly benefited from the fielding of non-Queenslanders, and in particular New South Welshman, in their teams. Not only has Queensland done it substantially more often and for greater periods of time, but Queensland has shown double the dependency on non-Queensland players for their series victories.
The data also reveals a dramatic increase in the use of non-QLD players by Queensland over the last 20-years. There appears to be a direct correlation between the three series victories in a row for NSW from 1993 to 1995 and the change in percentage of non-QLD players to appear in the QLD team since. The Super League war was no-doubt a key driver of this shift, but it is one that has extended all the way through to today. In fact, since 1995, in 15 of the 20 series more than 25% of the QLD team have not been Queenslanders. In correlation, NSW has only exceeded 10% of their team being non-New South Welshman five times, and never surpassed 14%.
During this period, QLD has won 11 series and NSW 7 while two were drawn. Furthermore, during these 20 years, non-QLD players contributing to the Maroons have been predominantly from NSW. Whereas for NSW, they have been solely from overseas birth. It’s just the start of some very intriguing data – read on for more.
Note: The following data specifically focused on place of birth, the truest indicator of affiliation.
How many QLD players are not true Queenslanders?
Of the 179 Queensland players used in State of Origin, 17 were from NSW, 3 were from another state altogether, and 12 were actually born overseas – the total is 32. Together this reveals that 17.9% of the players to run onto the paddock for the Maroons, are not true Queenslanders. 9.5% of the individuals who played for QLD were actually New South Welshman by birth.
How many NSW players are not true New South Welshman?
Of the 257 NSW players used in State of Origin, 4 were from QLD, 6 were from another state altogether, and 10 were actually born overseas – the total is 20. Together this reveals that 7.8% of the players to run onto the paddock for the cockroaches are not true New South Welshman. 1.6% of the individuals who played for NSW were actually Queenslanders by birth.
|Where the players from each state were born||Rival state||Other states||Overseas||Local State||Total|
How many games have non-QLD players contributed to QLD?
Between them, the 32 non-QLD players playing for QLD have a combined contribution of 246 games. 166 of these were specifically contributed by players actually born in NSW. 87 of these 166 contributions were in winning games, which is a 9.78% of overall winning contributions by players to the Queensland cause.
How many games have non-NSW players contributed to NSW?
Between them, the 20 non-NSW players playing for NSW have a combined contribution of 130 games. 29 of these were specifically contributed by players actually born in QLD. 13 of these 29 contributions were in winning games, which is a 1.71% of overall winning contributions by players to the NSW cause.
|Combined game contribution of players||Rival state||Other states||Overseas||Local State|
The pure team
Of the 33 full series, only 7 times has QLD fielded a team comprised solely of Queenslanders. All of these occurred between 1983 and 1991. For NSW, it has only fielded an all NSW team six times, and it happened in a row between 1996 and 2001.
Series by series breakdown of who has fielded the most amount of non-state players
In the 33 full series, on nine occasions NSW has had a greater percentage of non-NSW players in its side than QLD has had non-Queenslanders in its side. Thus QLD has had a greater percentage in 24 series. Of the 33 full series, on six times NSW has fielded more QLD players than QLD has fielded NSW players. On four occasions the percentage has been the same. In the other 23 series, QLD has fielded more NSW players than NSW has fielded QLD players.
In fact, NSW has not fielded a player born in QLD since 1995. QLD has not fielded a team without a NSW born player since 1991.
Series victories versus player birth
Of the 18 series that QLD has won, it had the greater percentage of non-State players in its side on 14 of those occasions – revealing a 77.8% dependency. Of the 13 series that NSW has won, on five of those occasions it had the higher percentage of non-State players across the series – revealing a 38.5% dependency.
The number of times a non-Queenslander has contributed to a series for QLD
Of the 32 non-QLD players to have played for QLD that have contributed a combined total of 126 times to a series – a total of 17.62% of all contributions. 70 of these contributions came on behalf of NSW born players – a total of 9.79% of all contributions.
The number of times a non-New South Welshman has contributed to a series for NSW
Of the 20 non-NSW players to have played for NSW that have contributed a combined total of 62 times to a series – a total of 7.91% of all contributions. 14 of these contributions came on behalf of QLD born players – a total of 1.79% of all contributions.
Which points were truly earned?
Points contributed by non-NSW players for New South Wales
Since 1980, 1576 points have been scored for NSW. 12 of these were scored by Queenslanders, 44 from players of other states, and 32 by overseas players. In total 5.6% of NSW points were not scored by New South Welshman. 0.8% scored by Queenslanders.
Points contributed by non-QLD players for Queensland
Since 1980, 1681 points have been scored for NSW. 219 of these were scored by Queenslanders, 12 from players of other states, and 56 by overseas players. In total 5.6% of NSW points were not scored by New South Welshman. In total 17.1% of QLD points were not scored by Queenslanders. 13% scored by New South Welshman.
|State||Rival state||Other states||Overseas||Local state|
Top QLD-born players to contribute to NSW
- Peter Sterling - 13 Games
- Chris Johns - 10 Games
- Steve Rogers - 4 Games
- Ken Nagas - 2 Games
- Overall Winning % = 44.8%
Top NSW-born players to contribute to QLD
- Greg Inglis – 24 Games
- Sam Thaiday – 22 Games
- Billy Moore – 17 Games
- Michael Crocker – 13 Games
- Robbie O'Davis – 12 Games
- Paul Bowman – 12 Games
- Julian O'Neill – 10 Games
- Chris Flannery – 10 Games
- Wayne Bartrim – 9 Games
- Matt Gillett – 9 Games
- Israel Folau – 8 Games
- Craig Greenhill – 6 Games
- Mat Rogers – 5 Games
- Norm Carr – 4 Games
- John Dowling – 3 Games
- Gary Smith – 1 Game
- Scott Sattler – 1 Game
- Overall Winning % = 52.4%
List of players who never should have played State of Origin because they were born overseas
- Benny Elias
- Mario Fenech
- Phil Blake
- Ian Roberts
- John Hopoate
- Willie Mason
- Hazem El Masri
- James McManus
- Akuila Uate
- James Tamou
- Chris Phelan
- Adrian Lam
- Brad Thorn
- Craig Smith
- Tonie Carroll
- Lote Tuqiri
- Petero Civoniceva
- Karmichael Hunt
- Neville Costigan
- Antonio Kaufusi
- Ben Te'o
- Josh Papalii
List of players who never should have played State of Origin because they were born in another state
- Bradley Clyde
- Timana Tahu
- Peter Wallace
- Joel Monaghan
- Justin Poore
- Josh Dugan
- Tony Hearn
- Willie Tonga
- Will Chambers
More guides on Finder
The top 50 rookie performances in State of Origin history revealed
The ultimate in State of Origin stats is here! Find out which rugby league players made the biggest impact in their State of Origin debuts.
Ask an Expert