First homebuyers accessing super to buy property is ‘irresponsible’, experts say
- 37 of 38 experts think the cash rate will hold for April 2017; 86% think the next move will be a rise
- 80% of panelists believe first home buyers shouldn’t access their super for property purchases
- In a low rate setting, experts think some borrowers may have over-borrowed
3 April, 2017, Sydney, Australia – Allowing first homebuyers access to their superannuation to fund property purchases is frowned upon by Australian experts and economists, while the cash rate is likely to stay at 1.5% at tomorrow’s board meeting (4th April, 2017), according to finder.com.au, Australia’s most visited comparison website1.
finder.com.au’s RBA cash rate survey, the largest of it’s kind in Australia, shows 37 of 38 experts and economists are expecting the Reserve Bank to hold the cash rate for April 2017.
However, there’s increased sentiment of a more positive future economic outlook with 86% of the 36 economists who weighed in on this question forecasting the next rate move to be an increase. This is up from 68% of panelists in March and 58% in February.
Only five experts and economists believe the rate will fall below 1.5%, with three predicting it will bottom-out at 1.00%
Rate rises will be a long time coming, however, as 70% of those who gave detailed predictions (34) indicating a rise will not take place until 2018.
Graham Cooke, Insights Manager, at finder.com.au, says mortgage holders should brace themselves for rising interest rates.
“The cash rate hasn’t shifted in recent months, but it’s now becoming clear that the next move will be in a positive direction as the Bank starts to tighten monetary policy.
“Variable rate mortgage holders should brace themselves and revise their household budget to ensure they can cope with higher mortgage repayments.
“This could mean consolidating personal debt or cutting back on household expenses such as utilities or groceries,” he says.
When asked if first home buyers should be allowed to access their superannuation to help with a property purchase, the majority of experts (80%, 24) said this would be ‘irresponsible’.
Mr Cooke supports this view, and says that enabling first home buyers to dip into their super funds could interfere with retirement planning.
“Allowing young Australians to access their super to facilitate a property purchase could jeopardise their future as it may mean they don’t have enough funds to cover living expenses once they hit retirement age.
“Additionally, this could add fuel to the fire by creating further demand for housing, thereby ballooning property prices,” he says.
In a low interest rate setting, experts were asked if some borrowers may have overborrowed for properties, and the responses were varied.
The majority of experts (11 of 18) think some new owner occupiers and investors may have overborrowed in the current market, especially in Sydney and Melbourne.
“Some first home buyers may have bitten off more than they can chew which could be an issue with rising rates. However, disciplined budgeting and a clear repayment schedule will help borrowers manage their debt effectively.
“APRA’s recent move to tighten mortgage rules combined with recent bank rate hikes, targeted mostly at investors, are likely to cool the flourishing housing market.
“In particular, APRA’s decision to limit the flow of new interest-only lending to 30% of new residential mortgages will have change the market drastically. Currently, interest-only loans account for 39% of lending,” Mr Cooke says.
Here’s what our experts had to say:
Jordan Eliseo, ABC Bullion (Hold): "The RBA has made it clear they are reticent to cut rates further, despite economic conditions that we'd characterise as soft on the whole."
Shane Oliver, AMP Capital (Hold): "Underlying inflation risks staying below target for longer and the Australian Dollar is too high, but growth is ok. National income is rising and the Sydney and Melbourne property markets are too hot. So best to stay on hold."
John Hewson, Australian National University (Hold): "There’s Insufficient evidence of the economy slowing and they’re waiting for the Budget"
Alison Booth, Australian National University (Hold): "I think the RBA will hold the cash rate owing to the stability of the key macroeconomic indicators."
Darryl Gobbett, Baillieu Holst (Hold): "RBA has more concern about the systemic issues with higher debt likely to result from lower interest rates than it sees benefits from lower interest rates."
Richard Robinson, BIS Oxford Economics (Hold): "Although domestic economy is still weak and the Australian Dollar is tracking too high, the overheating residential property market precludes a cut to rates. A rate cut would help put downward pressure on the Australian dollar.”
Michael Blythe, CBA (Hold): "[Current issues include] low inflation and housing concerns."
Savanth Sebastian, CommSec (Hold): "The RBA is comfortable how the economy is evolving. Rate cuts are not on the agenda and inflation remains contained."
Dr Andrew Wilson, Domain Group (Hold): "No real case for change this month, steady as she goes but economy still needs work - and Budget looming."
Saul Eslake, Economist (Hold): "Notwithstanding the most recent labour force data, which were disappointing, there is no compelling reason for the RBA to think that its most recent forecasts need to be revised down, or that monetary policy settings need to be eased further. On the contrary, the recent renewed strength in property investment lending is a strong argument against further easing - even if it doesn't constitute a case, on its own, for an immediate tightening."
Dr Mark Brimble, Griffith Uni (Hold): "The economy is still struggling to gather momentum with employment weakening and inflation lack luster. Confidence is also below trend. Financial Institutions have also been raise rates out of cycle and thus have increased pressure on the economy."
Peter Haller, Heritage Bank (Hold): "There is nothing in the underlying economic data to justify a change in rates."
Shane Garrett, Housing Industry Association (Hold): "The bank will see no pressing need for an interest rate change at this stage. Economic growth is performing reasonably well in most areas and inflation is not yet a threat."
Alex Joiner, IFM Investors (Hold): "No compelling shift in data or outlook justifies rates being kept on hold."
Robert Montgomery, Infrastructure Partnerships Australia (Hold): "The RBA will wait for more movement in underlying economic indicators."
Michael Witts, ING Bank (Hold): "No drivers have been identified that would suggest that the RBA is looking at changing the absolute level of the cash rate in the immediate period ahead."
Nicholas Gruen, Lateral Economics (Hold): "It's been telegraphed and they don't like changing rates unless they feel obliged to."
Leanne Pilkington, Laing+Simmons (Hold): "Not enough has changed in an economic sense since the RBA met in early March. The main indicators suggest any increase in rates in the near term could put undue pressure on markets and consumers."
Lynne Jordan, Liberty (Hold): "Household debt levels, low wage growth, active property investors and a weak inflationary environment still present a major policy challenge for the RBA. I don’t think we’ll know exactly when the RBA’s next move will be until CPI data comes out at the end of April. If Inflation has gone up, we lean closer towards the rate increase many economists have predicted. But if it is the same or lower, the RBA will likely hold the cash rate and remain in the same predicament it has been for the past few months – that investors will continue to make the most of low interest rates and drive up prices, which could result in household debt levels increasing even further."
Matthew Tiller, LJ Hooker (Hold): "There has been little discernible change[to] economic indicators since the last RBA meeting. GDP has rebounded, inflation remains soft and employment growth has kept ticking over. The east coast housing markets remain strong and continues to be of concern to the RBA, especially when factoring the recent rises in mortgage rates from the majority of banks. These factors combined should see the RBA hold rates steady this month and over the short term."
Stephen Koukoulas, Market Economics (Hold): "It has an unhealthy emphasis on Sydney and Melbourne housing which is preventing it from cutting interest rates."
John Caelli, ME (Hold): "Risks to house prices outweigh concerns about low inflation in the short term"
Michael Yardney, Metropole Property Strategists (Hold): "Underlying economic growth, though a little better than the previous quarter, is still weak but the RBA can't cut rates because of its concern regarding the strength in the Melbourne and Sydney property markets"
Mark Crosby, Monash University (Hold): "The well telegraphed Fed rate rise is consistent with more normal US growth, and outside Europe and Japan the global environment is reasonably benign. The case for a rate rise is not yet strong enough to justify moving rates up, but further Fed rises later this year should lead the RBA to consider increasing rates in H2."
Emily Dabbs, Moody's Analytics (Hold): "Inflation pressures are starting to build, but the domestic demand remains constrained by high underemployment. The central bank is keeping a close watch on the hot housing property, and further easing is unlikely while household debt continues to grow strongly. "
Jessica Darnbrough, Mortgage Choice (Hold): "I think the Reserve Bank will once again take a wait and see approach to interest rates. At present, there is nothing in the global or domestic economies that would push the Board to change their current stance on monetary policy. "
Christopher Schade, MyState Bank (Hold): "The hurdle for another cut is high. While inflation remains subdued, and the outlook for economic growth over the next year couple of years slightly below trend, interest rate settings in Australia are very accommodative and remain appropriate at their current level."
Alan Oster, NAB (Hold): "[The RBA is] still watching."
Jonathan Chancellor, Property Observer (Hold): "No need for any decision but hold. This year has seen continued upwards pressure on Sydney and Melbourne house prices, but standby for a shift given the continued regulatory measures and out of cycle bank rate hikes."
Matthew Peter, QIC (Hold): "The hot state of the housing market will keep the RBA from cutting rates, while the tepid recovery in the economy and lack of wage growth and core inflation will keep the RBA from raising rates - RBA on hold through 2017 and the first half of 2018."
Noel Whittaker, QUT (Hold): "No reason to move either way."
Janu Chan, St.George Banking Group (Increase): "The RBA is needing to balance a mixed outlook for the domestic economy and risks in the housing market. It suggests that the RBA will likely remain on hold in coming months."
Steven Milch, Suncorp (Hold): "Low inflation is being balanced by sound growth and a buoyant property market."
Brian Parker, Sunsuper (Hold): "Little change in the growth or inflation outlook from the previous meeting."
Clement Tisdell, UQ-School of Economics (Hold): "No indication from the governor of the Bank of a change."
Nicki Hutley, Urbis (Hold): "RBA does not want to exacerbate house price growth."
Bill Evans, Westpac (Hold)
Christine, Williams (Hold): "[The] employment rate has stayed the same with a mixture of casual and part time work employment No new full time work offered. Resources have not increased. With Cyclone Debbie's aftermath and the expectation of food rice increases this would not be the month to increase rates."
1 Experian Hitwise since 2015
For further information
The information in this release is accurate as of the date published, but rates, fees and other product features may have changed. Please see updated product information on finder.com.au's review pages for the current correct values.
More than 3 million Australians turn to finder.com.au every month to save money, time and make important life choices. We compare virtually everything from credit cards, phone plans, health insurance, travel deals and much more.
Our free service is 100% independently-owned by two Australians: Fred Schebesta and Frank Restuccia. Since launching in 2006, we’ve helped our users make more than 17 million decisions.
We continue to expand and launch around the globe, and now operate in the United States and United Kingdom. For further information visit www.finder.com.au.