Need a new NBN router? We compare 17 of the best models on the market

Krishan Sharma 18 July 2017

modems 738

Moving to the NBN may require a new router, but how do you choose the best one? We put 17 models to the test to find out which one reigns supreme.

Not all modem routers are created equal. Some offer better Internet connection speeds and drop out less than others, while others can potentially lock your port altogether leaving you without an Internet connection for up to 48 hours. Similarly, Wi-Fi performance varies wildly from model to model with some more suited to smaller living areas, such as apartments, and others able to accommodate larger households with more simultaneous users. A router with a modem built in might be more convenient than having to run two dedicated devices but finding an all-in-one unit that doesn’t compromise in either department can be more challenging.

This is particularly true with FTTN services where connection speeds can vary by a much wider margin than with ADSL, depending on the modem you have connected. In fact, our tests revealed that the difference in sync speeds (the speed at which the modem is synchronising with the NBN network) between the lowest and best-performing modem routers was more than 20 percent. This means that you can gain a significant boost in your NBN Internet speeds by simply picking the right modem router for the job.

But picking the right unit can feel like a guessing game and buying the most expensive model doesn’t necessarily mean you will get the best speeds from your FTTN connection either. In a lot of cases, the more expensive models performed worse in terms of Internet connection speeds than some of the more budget-oriented models. For this reason, we took it upon ourselves to test a large number of FTTN-compatible modem routers currently available on the market to see how they really stack up, so you can make a more informed purchasing decision. Here’s what we found.

Note: All modem routers listed here have a minimum of four LAN ports and wireless 802.11ac. All of the units were tested with the latest firmware available at the time of writing.

D-Link DSL-2877AL ($99)

DLink DSL-2877ALThe D-Link DSL-2877AL is a budget modem router that is available at retail and also via select ISPs. We suggest steering well clear of this one. Firstly, the 2877AL struggled to maintain an Internet connection for longer than a few days without dropping out. Worse still, the router would fail to reconnect automatically, prompting us to manually power cycle the router to restore the Internet connection.

At first, we thought it might be just a faulty unit so we swapped it over for a fresh retail model, but the dropouts continued at roughly the same frequency. We also tested another unit that was provided to us by the ISP and that too produced similar results. Connection times were average at around ten minutes and the sync speeds (75.8Mbps down and 30.5Mbps up) that the DSL-2877AL could muster were the lowest recorded out of all of the modems tested.

Configuring the modem was a real chore thanks to the severely outdated UI of the administration section and, in our experience, it was quite buggy. For instance, configuring our external USB drive so that it can serve files over the network caused the unit to crash altogether. Interestingly, the 2877AL boasts two USB ports but no Gigabit Ethernet so what we’re left with is four 10/100Mbps LAN ports. The range and speed of the Wi-Fi weren't anything to write home about and the reliability of the signal was also inconsistent with the 2.4GHz band dropping out some days while other days the 5GHz would fall victim.


Netcomm NF8AC ($149)

Netcomm-NF8ACWe were mightily impressed with the performance of Netcomm’s NF8AC budget-priced modem router. It was one of the fastest to connect, with the unit establishing an Internet connection within four minutes. The NF8AC also achieved fast sync speeds (85/42.2) and maintained a reliable connection throughout our five-day test period without any dropouts.

The router also comes equipped with four full-speed Gigabit ports. While the NF8AC's small size and lack of external antennas mean that it was never going to deliver outstanding Wi-Fi range or speeds, it performed well enough in our testing for a sub-$150 router and should be adequate for apartments and smaller homes. The NF8AC doesn’t offer much in the way of extra bells and whistles with a dated and stripped back user interface, but it gets the job done and regular users are likely to appreciate the lack of complexity. If you want to get the most from your FTTN connection at a budget price, then the NF8AC would be our recommendation.

Buy Netcomm NF8AC Modem Router from mwave

View details

Linksys X6200 ($179)

Linksys X6200The Linksys X6200 is the only modem router on the list to use a Realtek processing chip, so we were curious to see what sort of sync speeds it would achieve on FTTN. We quickly found out why very few modem routers use Realtek, with the X6200 delivering the slowest downstream speed of 68.5Mbps, which is over a 20% reduction in speeds when compared to some of the other modem routers on the list.

The X6200 also doesn't offer much in the way of tweakable settings to increase the speeds. The upstream connection speed was in line with the average, kicking in at a respectable 37.5Mbps. The Linksys comes equipped with entry level Wi-Fi (rated at up to theoretical speeds of 750Mbps), which we found to be fine for basic online activities like web browsing and email but certainly not suited to high bandwidth tasks such as 4K media streaming or accommodating any more than a handful of devices. At $179, the X6200 is definitely overpriced for what it delivers, especially when there are other budget-priced options like the Netcomm NF8AC or TP-Link VR600 that offer much more bang for the buck.


TP-Link VR600 ($189)

TP Link VR600The VR600 is the cheapest modem router in this round-up to use a Broadcom chip, going for around $189. It also offers 802.11ac wireless rated at 1600 Mbps which is rare at this price point. It also has a number of other features going for it such as the ability to add 3G/4G connectivity via the onboard USB port so you can use a mobile network as a backup or a primary Internet connection and the ability to manage the router via your smartphone with the dedicated TP-Link Tether app. While most modem routers force you to do the initial set-up over a wired connection, TP-Link gives you the option to go through the entire process using the smartphone app.

The process was seamless and we were up and running within five minutes. TP-Link’s connection wizard also offers a very large list of pre-configured ISPs, saving you from having to enter in your ISP’s preferred settings manually. The dedicated app allows you to manage a number of handy features of the router while on the go including parental controls so you can schedule the kids' Internet or turn it on and off from your smartphone. Regardless of whether you’re managing the VR600 via a web browser or app, the interface is nicely designed and very easy to navigate.

In terms of sync speeds, the VR600 delivered 84.3/41.4 Mbps. We noticed that the unit was dropping Internet connectivity on occasion but enabling SRA within the DSL settings fixed that issue. We’re not sure why TP-Link decided to disable SRA by default. Wi-Fi performance was comparable to the other AC1600-rated modem routers we looked at. It is good enough for a small household of four to five people but larger homes or people using more devices simultaneously will need to step up to something more capable.

It’s also worth noting that there’s no dedicated WAN port so you will need to sacrifice one of the four Gigabit Ethernet ports if you later need to connect to a different type of NBN service. All in all, we were pleasantly surprised with the $189 VR600. The only other contender in the sub-$200 range that can match it in terms of connection speeds is the Netcomm NF8AC, but the VR600 edges ahead with a richer feature set and a far superior user interface.

Buy TP-Link Archer VR600 Modem Router from mwave

View details

Asus DSL-AC52U ($139), DSL-AC56U ($199), DSL-AC68U ($279)

Asus DSL-AC56UAll three of Asus’s modem routers, the DSL-AC52U, the AC56U and the AC68U, run the risk of port locking unless the latest firmware is installed before connecting to an FTTN service. We experienced this first hand. In the case of the AC52U, we first tested the unit back in March using the latest firmware available at the time (version 1.1.2.2_34) and our port was immediately locked due to the firmware disabling certain settings that NBN Co requires to be enabled on their network by default. After speaking with Asus, who assured us that the latest firmware rectifies the port-locking issues, we decided to test the unit again and we are happy to report that both the DSL-AC52U and DSL-AC56U running the latest firmware (version 1.1.2.3_288) connected without issue.

With the DSL-AC68U, Asus recommends updating to the latest available firmware (version 3.0.0.4.380_7712 at the time of writing) to ensure a smooth connection with FTTN services. Note that retail units are likely to ship with outdated firmware, so you will need to first update the firmware, reset the unit back to factory settings after updating the firmware and then finally connect the RJ11 phone cable and run the Internet set-up wizard. Asus boasts a nice modern user interface to manage their modem routers.

All three models also have USB ports that support 3G/4G dongles with the ability to switch instantly between connections if one fails (and switch back again when it’s fixed) or combine multiple connections for more bandwidth. The DSL-AC68U ramps up Wi-Fi performance, adds a USB 3.0 port and throws in two CPUs that Asus claims do a better job of optimising Internet connectivity and Wi-Fi. Asus DSL-AC52U Unfortunately, all three models handed in abysmal Internet connection speeds. The AC52U, AC56U and AC68U registered speeds of just 75.2/38.5, 75.6/38.7 and 75.7/35.6 respectively. Asus’s decision to go with a MediaTek modem chipset on all three models is likely the culprit here, resulting in speeds that are almost on par with D-Link’s 2877AL which also uses MediaTek. To Asus’s credit, they do offer a number of tools that you can use to improve sync speeds.

Enabling the stability adjustment under DSL settings, for instance, bumped up speeds to 79.2/40.1Mbps on the DSL-AC68U, which is a good result for the upload speed but the downstream speeds still lagged behind a lot of the other modem routers in this round-up. Outside of the lacklustre modem performance, Asus includes some useful features such as network protection from Trend Micro that can be set up with a few clicks to automatically block malicious sites and other spyware from any devices connected to the network. Asus DSL-AC68U In addition, there’s a security assessment feature which essentially scans your router’s settings and gives you a summary of what settings you should enable or disable. And if you don’t feel comfortable in playing around with the settings, a single tap of the "secure" button will do it all for you. We also need to commend Asus for implementing perhaps the most detailed and easy to understand traffic analyser on a router, so you can see at a glance what online sites and services are being accessed from the devices connected to your network.

Unfortunately, we found the Wi-Fi performance on both the AC52U and the AC56U fairly unreliable. The 5GHz band frequently dropped out, prompting us to reboot the router to get it functioning again. The AC68U’s Wi-Fi, on the other hand, was rock solid and there’s enough bandwidth there to accommodate the demands of a typical household. Ultimately, we can’t recommend these three Asus models to anyone looking to get the best possible Internet connection speeds from their FTTN service.


D-Link DSL-2888A ($229) and D-Link DVA-2800 ($279)

DLink DVA2800Both the DSL-2888A and the DVA-2800 from D-Link are the only two models in the round-up to use silicon from Chinese chip maker Triductor, who has made a name for itself by racking up some impressive sync speeds that go toe-to-toe with industry giant Broadcom. So do these two Triductor-equipped modem routers deliver the goods? In a word, yes. But before we get into that, let’s take a closer look at the two units themselves.

Firstly, both the DSL-2888A (Python) and the DVA-2800 (TalkBox) come equipped with an identical feature set but the latter has phone ports for VOIP bolted on and costs roughly $50 more. Both units are still competitively priced with the Python going for around $230 and the DVA coming in at $280. The user interface uses the same modern web-based user interface as our premium modem router of choice, the Taipan (DSL-4320L), as opposed to the dated UI found on D-Link’s entry level unit, the DSL-2877AL.

This means that getting connected for the first time was a simple four-step process and we were up and running within five minutes. DLink DSL-2888AOnce connected, we were greeted with chart-topping speeds of 88.3 Mbps downstream from both the Python and TalkBox, which matches the top tier speeds set by the Taipan. However, it didn’t do as well in terms of upload speeds, achieving only 37.3Mbps as opposed to the Taipan’s 41.2 Mbps but this is still very respectable. Incidentally, both the Python and TalkBox achieved the exact same sync speeds of 88.3/37.3, which suggests the units are using identical Triductor modem chips. Boot times were also most impressive, with an active Internet connection established in under four minutes from turning the units on and the connection remained rock solid without any dropouts over the course of five days.

The AC1600 Wi-Fi performed as expected, delivering adequate range for a small house or apartment and able to cope with HD streaming on multiple devices. Streaming 4K content on a single device over Wi-Fi also worked fine but firing up multiple 4K streams was enough to choke the Wi-Fi, which is to be expected for an AC1600-rated unit. For that and other high bandwidth tasks, you’re going to need to step up to either the Taipan or Netgear’s D8500.

If you’re after the best possible Internet connection speeds with decent Wi-Fi without breaking the bank, then the $230 Python is the way to go. For those who plan on plugging in phones for VOIP, the DVA-2800 is a good option but the Fritz!Box also might be worth considering as it offers more features in this department, but it comes at the cost of slightly slower connection speeds.

Buy D-Link Python DSL-2888A Modem Router
mwave
Buy D-Link TalkBox DVA-2800 Modem Router
mwave

Fritz!Box 7490 ($249)

AVM FritzBox 7490The Fritz!Box 7490 packs quite a number of features for a unit that is fairly compact in size. On top of being a wireless modem router, it also acts as a DECT phone base station, answering machine, call blocker and also redirects faxes to your email. You can even access your landline from your mobile phone by using the Fritz! app for iOS or Android.

In terms of modem performance, we were impressed with how quickly we were able to get up and running with a straightforward wizard that stepped us through the connection process without issues. From boot, it took under five minutes for the modem to establish an Internet connection, which remained rock solid throughout the five days of testing. At 84.1Mbps down and 37.8Mbps, the sync speeds weren’t particularly high when compared to some of the other modems we tested.

The 7490 also lacks a dedicated WAN port which means you’ll need to sacrifice one of the four Gigabit LAN ports if you plan to connect this unit to NBN’s FTTP service later on down the road. On the upside, the Fritz Box does offer comprehensive administrative sections that show you everything you could possibly want to know about your Internet connection, including the maximum throughput being supplied by the node you’re connected to right down to the Broadcom chipset model number that the node is using. There’s a lot of information to sink your teeth into but thankfully it’s laid out in a way that is fairly easy to understand and navigate.

There are also thoughtful touches sprinkled throughout the modem router’s features set. For instance, if a device is still using Wi-Fi past the user-defined scheduled time, then it will intelligently wait until no one is using Wi-Fi before disabling. Not having external antennas, the 7490 doesn't have the best possible wireless range and there's no option to add antennae if you wish, so you're stuck with whatever performance you get straight out of the box.

The Fritz!Box supports 1300Mbps on the 5GHz AC band and 450Mbps over 2.4GHz 802.11n. The wireless performed fine within a 10-metre range of the router, but anything outside of that range resulted in dramatically reduced speeds. Still, it should be adequate enough to keep up with the demands of a small household or apartment, but the garish red and grey industrial design means that you’re going to want to hide this unit in a cupboard somewhere.

Buy AVM Fritz!Box 7490 from mwave

View details

Telstra Gateway Max 2 ($264)

Telstra Gateway Max 2The Telstra Gateway Max 2 boasts a number of features not normally found on other routers, such as onboard NFC for easy Wi-Fi pairing to Android smartphones and a physical button to turn the Wi-Fi on and off. However, you cannot set a schedule to turn the Wi-Fi on and off between certain times, so you will need to do this manually. It also has a stylish design and comes with a stand so that the router can rest upright.

Despite being available only through Telstra, the Gateway Max 2 modem will work with other ISPs with some caveats. For one, the firmware is not upgradeable on a non-Telstra connection and there is no way to upgrade it manually. Also, the modem will attempt to "phone home" every few days causing the Internet connection to drop out completely. It can take a while to reconnect after a reboot as well.

Meanwhile, we didn’t experience any dropouts while using a Telstra FTTN connection. It’s worth keeping these drawbacks in mind if you’re switching from Telstra to another ISP with the Gateway Max 2 in tow. Overall, the modem is very easy to use, but this comes at the cost of a limited suite of administration features especially when compared to other modem routers available on the market at this price point. On the upside, the Gateway Max 2 provided some of the fastest sync speeds during our testing (86.04/42.7), and it is also equipped with the most capable Wi-Fi at the sub-$300 price point.

For Telstra users, the Gateway Max 2 is an easy choice. However, if you’re coming across from Telstra and were contemplating on using your Gateway Max 2 on another ISP’s FTTN service, then the regular dropouts and the inability to update the firmware might not be worth the frustration.


Netgear D7000 ($279)

Netgear D7000The Netgear D7000 was a real mixed bag. It handed in good sync speeds (85.78/42.06) and a stable connection, but it was painfully slow in establishing an Internet connection, generally taking up to 20 minutes to connect from booting up. We also experienced a number of issues with the unit’s Wi-Fi performance, chief among those were the regular dropouts that forced us to reboot the unit. The speed and range of the Wi-Fi were decidedly average and certainly not up to the standard of some of the other modem routers in its price bracket. What’s more, one of the four Gigabit Ethernet ports completely died during our testing.

We also found the router’s management interface quite buggy and sluggish. Setting up a Wi-Fi schedule, for instance, would end up disabling the Wi-Fi well past the scheduled hours, forcing us to use a wired connection to re-enable Wi-Fi on every occasion. We even tried another fresh retail unit to rule out the possibility of a faulty unit but the same issues persisted.


Netgear D7800 ($399)

Netgear D7800 copyThe Netgear D7800 offers a lot of the same features as the D7000, but with much faster and farther reaching Wi-Fi. What's more, the new router now supports MU-MIMO, an increasingly popular feature that helps boost speeds for supported Wi-Fi clients in a crowded home. We’re also happy to report that we didn’t experience any of the Wi-Fi issues that were present on the D7000. On the modem front, the modem chipset was switched from a Broadcom chip to a Lantiq chip, which produced lower sync speeds (82.5Mbps/37.2Mbps). Sadly, it still uses the same sluggish web interface as previous Netgear routers.

This means that the set-up process to get connected for the first time is still excruciatingly slow. It took us over 20 minutes to get through the set-up thanks to the wizard stalling at various stages. Once connected, the D7800 maintained a rock solid connection without any drops during our test period and the connection time from a reboot was around 8 minutes, which is much improved from the D7000 but still twice as long as some of the other modem routers we tested. Unfortunately, the bloated web interface means that bouncing between different settings is far from a snappy experience and saving even the most minor of changes is accompanied by a loading screen that can take two to three minutes to get through.

If you can get past that, then the D7800 does offer some useful features such as a traffic monitor which you can set up to align with your ISP’s billing period so that you can track how much Internet data your household is using every month (handy if you suspect your ISP is getting "creative" with your recorded data usage). Parental control features are well implemented as well, giving you finite control so you can block certain sites from being accessed by each member of the household. You can have different filtering rules based on the time of day as well so you can block sites like YouTube from being accessed in the evenings during the kids' homework times.

But where the D7800 real strength lies is in its Wi-Fi performance. In our testing, the D7800 maintained a faster and more stable wireless signal and at greater distances than all of the other routers we tested at the sub-$400 price point. Our only knock against the D7800 in this department is in its inability to band together two network bands. Some other routers at this price bracket offer the very convenient option to band together both the 2.4GHz and 5GHz network bands under one network name but that’s not an option here. As such, you’re forced to run two separate network names if you want to take advantage of all the Wi-Fi performance the D7800 has to offer.

At $400, you would expect a modem router to perform in all departments, but that’s not what we get here. While we can’t really fault the D7800’s Wi-Fi performance, the low Internet speeds and connection times in addition to a sluggish UI makes the D7800 tough to recommend.


Billion 8900ax-2400 ($399)

Billion 8900AX-2400As is the case with Draytek, the Billion 8900ax-2400 is a modem router that is geared towards technical users or for those running a SOHO (small office/home office) as opposed to the average consumer. Operating the modem router is far from a user-friendly experience, but you also get access to more advanced features and settings than you would typically find in a consumer router.

Four Gigabit Ethernet ports adorn the rear, and three of these can be used as WAN ports, a unique selling point that allows multiple broadband connections. There’s also a single USB 2.0 port, making it possible to connect a 3G/4G USB mobile modem. If any of the WAN connections fail, the router automatically switches to the USB modem, a handy feature when reliability is a must. We would’ve liked to have seen a USB 3.0 to improve this unit’s capabilities as a basic NAS/file server. If you’re connecting an FTTN service to this unit, then you can configure the WAN port and use it as a LAN port, effectively making it five Gigabit Ethernet ports in total so you can connect more devices over the faster and more reliable wired connection.

The 8900ax uses a Broadcom modem chipset and, as such, the unit handed in decent sync speeds (84.2/37.1). Connection times were fairly quick at around five minutes and the connection was rock solid throughout the course of five days of testing. Similarly, Wi-Fi was also reliable, with no dropouts discovered. However, the speed and range of the Wi-Fi was a little underwhelming for an 802.11ac router rated at 2400 Mbps. At $400, there’s better value to be had elsewhere.


D-Link DSL-4320L Taipan ($499)

DLink DSL-4320L TAIPAND-Link’s DSL-4320L is an impressive looking modem router that actually performs as well as it looks. Upon booting up the unit, we were greeted with a connection wizard that has been streamlined down to just four simple steps, allowing us to get online in under five minutes, making it by of the quickest set-up processes we experienced. Those who’ve never set up a router before will find it a breeze to navigate as well. The user-friendly experience continues after set-up with the default landing screen of its web interface using pictorials to explain what’s going on and displaying only the information that is relevant, ensuring ordinary users won’t be overwhelmed by networking jargon.

The more advanced settings such as QoS, VPN, website filtering and static routes are all still there but are simply hidden behind a few clicks. The web-based user interface seamlessly scales to smartphones and tablets as well, so you have access to the same settings and features on the small screen without having to use a dedicated app. Crucially, the Taipan delivered the best sync speeds out of all the modems tested, delivering a whopping 88.3Mbps down and 41.2Mbps up.

Connection times were also the quickest recorded, with the unit securing an online connection in under four minutes from booting up. Meanwhile the "smartconnect" smartly merges all three network bands into one wireless network name and will automatically pair Wi-Fi devices with the clearest and fastest network at the time. Our only real qualm with the Taipan is the lack of a dedicated WAN port which means sacrificing one of the four Gigabit Ethernet ports if you move into premises that support NBN’s Fibre to the Premises connection later on down the road. At this price point, we would have liked to have seen more than four Gigabit Ethernet ports as well.

We also noticed during our testing that the unit was dropping Internet connectivity once a day. Digging into the advanced settings of the router, we discovered that SRA (Seamless Rate Adaptation) was disabled by default. NBN recommends having SRA enabled so that if the line condition drops too low, which can occur for brief periods of time on FTTN, the modem will adapt by momentarily lowering the sync speed instead of dropping the connection entirely. Sure enough, turning on SRA put an end to the dropout issue. Hopefully, D-Link releases a firmware update in the future that enables SRA by default.

Those missteps aside, the Taipan is a modem router that doesn’t compromise in either department, delivering the best Internet speeds and quickest connection time while also pushing out faster Wi-Fi to more devices and at a further range than all of the other modem routers in this round-up barring Netgear’s pricier D8500. Provided you have the cash to spare, the Taipan won’t disappoint.

Buy D-Link Taipan DSL-4320L Modem Router from mwave

View details

Draytek Vigor 2860vac ($599)

Draytek Vigor 2860acLike the Billion, the Draytek Vigor 2860vac is a business-focused modem router with advanced features such as the ability to run multiple broadband connections, failover support with 3G/4G and a suite of enterprise-grade security features. It can also accommodate a large number of wired devices with its six Gigabit Ethernet ports. However, to access any of these features, you’re going to need to dive into the router’s administration interface which is text-heavy and confusing at times.

It’s easy enough to set up the router for basic use but anything more advanced requires a lot of searching and digging through sub-menus. Ultimately, what makes a good modem router is its ability to deliver strong Internet connection speeds and Wi-Fi, but the Draytek was lacklustre in both departments. The connection speed of 81.2 Mbps down and 37.3 Mbps up is on the low side and the Wi-Fi, while stable, was below the mark in both range and speed when compared to consumer-grade modem routers.


Netgear D8500 ($729)

Netgear D8500The Netgear D8500 essentially takes one of the company’s top-of-the-line routers, the R8500, and crams a modem inside. This means that you get all of the bells and whistles normally reserved for a dedicated top-tier premium router such as tri-band and MU-MIMO that essentially delivers faster speeds to more devices simultaneously without the need to buy a separate modem to handle Internet connectivity.

Unfortunately, in our testing, we found the modem portion of the unit could do with some more work when it comes to FTTN connections in Australia. The firmware that the retail unit ships with lacks modem functionality, which is a bizarre oversight when you consider that most customers would be looking to connect the D8500 to their FTTN Internet service. Updating the firmware to version 1.0.3.27, which explicitly states "supports modem mode on firmware" in the release notes, we were able to progress further with the connection wizard and secure a line sync, but we couldn’t get the modem to establish an Internet connection with the ISP.

After some back and forth with the engineers at Netgear, we stumbled across a workaround. It turns out that the D8500 doesn’t play nice with Internet connections that require a login (also known as PPPoE), which a number of ISPs require customers to enter into their modems when connecting for the first time. Specifically, the D8500 fails to establish an IP address on the network in PPPoE mode. To get around this issue, we had to initially force the D8500 into DHCP mode (ie, no login) and then change it back to PPPoE once the wizard was finished so we could enter our ISP’s login details. Finally, we were able to connect. Netgear assures me that a firmware update will be released in the near future that rectifies this issue.

Once connected, the D8500 delivered impressive speeds clocking in at 87.5Mbps down and 37.2 Mbps up. It does take double the time to connect when compared to some of the other modem routers tested, taking eight minutes to get online after a reboot. And to manage the router, you’re going to once again have to deal with Netgear’s sluggish "Genie" interface. On the plus side, the D8500 boasts six Ethernet ports, two of which support port aggregation—a rarity in the consumer-router market. This means that you can connect up to six wired clients (servers, desktop computers, game consoles, etc.) with a superior Gigabit Ethernet connection or combine two of its ports to deliver a single super-fast wired connection to a compatible device like a NAS (Network Attached Storage) for faster file transfers.

The D8500 is really designed to keep up with the demands of a large family that has a very high number of active devices using Wi-Fi at the same time (think 10 or more concurrent devices). The R8500’s tri-band capabilities with MU-MIMO means it can spread a whopping 5.3Gbps of available bandwidth over three different bands to ensure all those connected devices receive the fastest possible speeds. It’s no surprise then that the R8500 delivered faster Wi-Fi speeds over a longer distance than all of the other modem routers in this round-up.

To put it to the test, we simultaneously streamed 4K content from Netflix, Stan and YouTube to four devices, uploaded a 10GB file to Google Drive from a Windows notebook while transferring a 70GB file from a 2017 MacBook Pro to our Synology NAS and the D8500 didn’t skip a beat. At $749, the D8500 is a pricey proposition and it’s not without its blemishes, including a far from ideal set-up process with FTTN services and a sluggish user interface. There are also other tri-band modem routers worth considering, such as D-Link’s Taipan DSL-4320L, which is not only a few hundred dollars cheaper but also delivered faster Internet speeds and connection times. With that said, if you have a large household that can make use of all the bandwidth that the D8500 has on offer, then this unit should be at the top of your list.

Buy Netgear D8500 Nighthawk Modem Router from mwave

View details

Compare all routers

BrandModelStreet priceFeaturesSync speeds (down/up Mbps)Dropouts (tested over 5 days)Port locking
D-LinkDSL-2877AL$994x 10/100 LAN | 1x WAN | 1x ADSL/VDSL (FTTN) | 2x USB 3.0 port | 802.11ac (750)75.8/30.5Yes, the router would drop the Internet connection on a regular basisNo
AsusDSL-AC52U$1394x Gigabit ports | 1x WAN | 1 x ADSL/VDSL (FTTN) | 1x USB 2.0 | 802.11ac (750)75.2/38.5No drop in Internet connection but Wi-Fi dropouts were frequent, prompting us to reboot the routerNo, provided firmware version 1.1.2.3_224 or higher is loaded before connecting
NetcommNF8AC$1494x Gigabit LAN | 1x WAN | 1x ADSL/VDSL (FTTN) | 802.11ac (1600) | 2x USB 3.085/42.2Nono
LinksysX6200$1794x Gigabit LAN | 1x WAN | 1x ADSL/VDSL (FTTN) | 1x USB 2.0 | 802.11ac (750)68.5/37.5NoNo
TP-LinkVR600$1893x Gigabit LAN | 1x WAN/LAN | 1x ADSL/VDSL (FTTN) | 1x USB 2.0 | 802.11ac (1600)84.3/41.4NoNo
AsusDSL-AC56U$1994x Gigabit LAN | 1x WAN | 1x ADSL/VDSL (FTTN) | 2x USB 2.0 | 802.11ac (1167)75.6/38.7No drop in Internet connection but Wi-Fi dropouts were frequent, prompting us to reboot the routerNo, provided firmware version 1.1.2.3_224 or higher is loaded before connecting
D-LinkDSL-2888A$2294x Gigabit LAN | 1x WAN | 1x ADSL/VDSL (FTTN) | 2x USB 3.0 | 802.11ac (1600)88.3/37.2NoNo
AVMFritz!Box 7490$2494x Gigabit LAN (WAN via LAN port 1) | 1x ADSL/VDSL (FTTN) | 2x USB 3.0 | 802.11ac (1750) VOIP84.1/37.8NoNo
TelstraTechnicolor TG800vac (Gateway Max 2)$2644x Gigabit LAN ports | 1x WAN port | 1x ADSL/VDSL (FTTN) | 2x USB 3.0 | 802.11ac (3100) | MU-MIMO NFC VOIP86.04/42.7Yes, every few days or so when connected to a non-Telstra ISP. No dropouts were found when connected to Telstra.No
D-LinkDVA-2800$2794x Gigabit LAN | 1x WAN | 1x ADSL/VDSL (FTTN) | 2x USB 3.0 | VOIP | 802.11ac (1600)88.3/37.2NoNo
NetgearD7000$2794 Gigabit LAN ports | 1x WAN | 1x ADSL/VDSL (FTTN) | 2x USB 3.0 | 802.11ac (1900)85.78/42.06No drop in Internet connection over the course of five days but Wi-Fi dropouts were frequent, prompting us to reboot the routerNo
AsusDSL-AC68U$2794x Gigabit LAN | 1x USB 3.0 | 1x ADSL/VDSL (FTTN) | 802.11ac (1900)75.7/35.6NoNo, provided firmware version 3.0.0.4.380_7361 or higher is loaded before connecting
Billion8900ax-2400$3995x Gigabit LAN/WAN | 1x ADSL/VDSL (FTTN) | 1x USB 2.0 | VOIP | 802.11ac (2400)84.2/37.1NoNo
NetgearD7800$3994x Gigabit LAN | 1x WAN | 1x ADSL/VDSL (FTTN) | 2x USB 3.0 | 1x eSata | 802.11ac (2600)82.5/37.2NoNo
D-LinkTaipan DSL-4320L$4994x Gigabit LAN | 1x ADSL/VDSL (FTTN) | 1x USB 3.0 | 1x USB 2.0 | 802.11ac (3200) Tri-band88.3/41.2NoNo
DraytekVigor 2860Vac$5996x Gigabit LAN | 1x WAN | 1x ADSL/VDSL (FTTN) | 2x USB 2.0 | 802.11ac (1600) VOIP81.2/36.7NoNo
NetgearD8500$7496x Gigabit LAN | 1x WAN | 1x ADSL/VDSL (FTTN) | 1x USB 3.0 | 1x USB 2.0 | 802.11ac (5300) Tri-band MU-MIMO87.2/37.2NoRequires firmware update to connect to FTTN services. Workaround required for PPPoE connections

Latest Broadband news

The latest broadband offers on finder

Ask an Expert

You are about to post a question on finder.com.au:

  • Do not enter personal information (eg. surname, phone number, bank details) as your question will be made public
  • finder.com.au is a financial comparison and information service, not a bank or product provider
  • We cannot provide you with personal advice or recommendations
  • Your answer might already be waiting – check previous questions below to see if yours has already been asked

Finder only provides general advice and factual information, so consider your own circumstances, read the PDS or seek advice before you decide to act on our content. By submitting a question, you're accepting our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.
Ask a question