Sony LF-S50G review

With its rich history in developing high-quality audio products for the masses, Sony’s first attempt at a smart speaker is a viable alternative to Google’s own Home speaker system, with some unique additions that help it stand apart from the crowd.

The LF-S50G’s inclusion of an LED clock, water resistance and gesture controls all help it claim a fairly unique position in the market, but it’s the impressive sound quality that will really sway you to this model over Google’s own speakers. Especially given that many of Sony’s unique integrations don’t seem to be thought through 100%.

Design

Design

• Simple and elegant design
• NFC support makes pairing quick and easy

• Read more about the LF-S50G's design

  There’s an elegant simplicity to the design of the LF-S50G smart speaker. Cylindrical in design with a black, white or blue mesh covering, the LF-S50G looks exactly like what it is.

  The glossy plastic bottom of the device houses the power jack, as well as dedicated buttons for muting the microphone (an essential inclusion in the smart speaker market) and Bluetooth, for easy connectivity.

  Beneath the speaker are two buttons so subtle you may not even notice they are there – a dimmer for the clock (which can switch it off), and a button that locks off gesture and touch controls for three minutes.

  About two-thirds of the way up the speaker’s mesh grill, there is an NFC chip for simple and quick device pairing (so long as you are using an Android device, that is), while the front of the speaker houses a two-line LED clock. Above the clock, four LED lights will flash when you say the essential “OK Google” hotword, indicating that the microphones are actively listening to what you’re saying.

  The top of the LF-S50G is marked by the iconic Sony badge, as well as two microphone holes on either side. The top is touch sensitive, allowing you to control the volume (if you touch it just right), and also includes sensors for the gesture control.

  From a design standpoint, the one major flaw is in the LF-S50G’s name. Competing with devices named “Echo” or “Home”, Sony’s decision to go with a product code as the key identifier for this speaker is somewhat confusing. But that’s not going to be a dealbreaker for anyone already considering Sony’s offering.

Performance

Performance

• Solid audio quality that beats out Amazon's Echo and Google's Home speakers
• Adjusting volume is more difficult than it should be
• Touch and gesture controls are clunky

• Read more about the LF-S50G's performance

  Sony is an audio company, so it’s not really a surprise that the sound quality from the LF-S50G is solid. It doesn’t come close to the much more expensive Apple HomePod, or even match the recently updated Sonos ONE speaker, but definitely sits above the Google Home and Amazon Echo family of speakers.

  In general scenarios, the sound is fairly balanced, maybe a little weak on the bass front, but not terribly so. Crank things up to full volume and that lack of bass is more noticeable, but the speaker manages to play back bass-heavy tracks without distortion.

  There is a weird flaw with the Google Assistant’s implementation of volume – while you can set the volume to any number out of 100, if you want it to sit at a number below 10, voice commands will instead set it at 10 times the number you request (so 50 when you ask for 5, for example).

  The touch panel on the top of the Sony will let you drop it down in increments of threes, which doesn’t give you a huge amount of granular control over volume.

  And also on the volume front, it’s important to note that the Sony’s volume setting isn’t recognised by the Google Assistant. So if you have the speaker’s volume set at the lowest possible setting, Google Assistant’s responses still come back at a standard (loud) volume.

  This makes things like setting an alarm late at night while everyone else is asleep something you won’t want to do with voice commands.

  

  Digital assistant performance

  The Google Assistant was the first smart speaker digital assistant to launch in Australia when it arrived with the Google Home, and the experience for users of the Sony LF-S50G is identical.

  Google Assistant will answer your questions about the weather, offer you news updates and tell you about your day by checking your Google calendar. It is full of Australian anecdotes and jokes, and offers a range of games and quizzes to help keep your kids happy.

  Unlike Alexa, Google Assistant can be paired with multiple Google accounts (including kids accounts using the family link app), and can detect different voices to give different, personalised responses.

  The platform also offers smart home controls, which allow you to use your voice to monitor all manner of devices around the home. After setting up the different rooms of my house in the Google Home app, I can easily switch on, off or change any of the Philips Hue globes I have located around the house. The voice recognition software of the Google Assistant does a good job of accurately hearing and then actioning my commands, with the Sony microphones picking up the commands at a reasonable volume from across the room.

  One of Google’s best implementations with the Google Assistant is the ability to send recipes found on a web browser to your smart speaker with a single button press. Then, with the right command, the speaker will read out a step by step guide while you cook.

  This functionality is especially useful for the Sony speaker given its splashproof design.

  Touch/gesture controls

  One of Sony’s unique selling points for the LF-S50G is the inclusion of touch and gesture controls on the top of the speaker. If you watch the promotional videos and images on Sony’s website, these are designed to allow for hands-free control, specifically in a kitchen environment where your hands might be covered in food or water and you don’t want to wipe it all over your shiny new speaker.

  The reality though is that neither gesture or touch controls work well, or intuitively. The touch panel, for example, can be used to control volume if you gently caress the top of the speaker in a circular motion. But it only works on a specific part of the top panel, which is not clearly marked, so that even after weeks of experience you rarely hit the right place on your first attempt.

  Gesture controls are similarly frustrating. Waving your hand from left to right over the top of the speaker is meant to skip forward a track, while right to left will rewind. Going from back to front activates the microphone so you don’t have to say “OK Google”, though it works so haphazardly you’ll never opt for this method.

  Front to back will play or pause your music, but it’s an awkward movement.

  And when it comes down to it, none of these functions is anything that the speaker can’t do with a voice command anyway, which makes you wonder why Sony bothered.

Verdict

Verdict

• A well-balanced speaker with a few too many unnecessary gimmicks

Should you buy it?

Sony’s first smart speaker is a mixed bag. At its core, it’s a finely balanced speaker that delivers the full Google Assistant experience to your home. Like the Google Home, the LF-S50G is a companion to your everyday life in a smart speaker format, with the ability to control your smart home and keep your kids entertained with fun audio-based games.

But Sony’s attempts to make the speaker unique with touch and gesture controls is a misfire that doesn’t add to the experience. And given you are paying for those features when you opt for this speaker, you may not feel it’s the best use of your dollars, especially in a rather price competitive market anyway.

Still, for the slight premium over the Google Home, you do get a better audio result, so if sound quality and Google Assistant are important to you, this could be the ideal speaker for you.

Pricing and availability

Price

RRP $249

Where to buy

Check availability at eBay

Check availability at Amazon

Catch

Specifications

Where to buy