Smart speaker review methodology
Here's how we break down the scores for our smart speaker reviews.
We’re reader-supported and may be paid when you visit links to partner sites. We don’t compare all products in the market, but we’re working on it!
Here at Finder, we rigorously test the smart speakers we review to determine scores for design and performance as well as an overall score. Each category is scored out of five, with zero being the lowest possible score.
This is how our reviewers break down each score:
To determine the design score, we consider:
- Aesthetics. What does it look like? Does it come in multiple colours or styles? Is there a display?
- Materials. What is it made out of? Does it feel cheap or high quality?
- Size and weight. How bulky is it? Is it easy to move from room to room?
- Functionality. Does the design make the speaker easier or harder to use? What physical controls does it have?
- Set-up. What's included in the box? How easy is it to set up the speaker?
To determine the performance score, we consider:
- Sound quality. How does the speaker sound? Is it clear and well-rounded? How dynamic is the bass?
- Smart assistant. Which smart assistant is included? Does it perform as promised?
- Voice detection. What is the microphone array? How well does the speaker pick up voice commands? How does it respond to different accents?
- Smart home compatibility. What products is the speaker compatible with? How easy is it to control them using the speaker?
- App. What can you do with the corresponding app? How easy is it to use?
- Privacy. Is there an option to turn off the microphones? If the speaker has a camera, is there a manual shutter?
The overall score is not an average of the other scores. To determine the overall score, the reviewer considers the scores for design and performance, the price and how it compares to other available smart speakers. For example, a speaker could have high scores for design and performance, but a high price tag might bring down the overall score.
When coming up with the overall score, we consider:
- Our overall impression of the product
- Value for money
- How it compares to the rest of the market
While our scores reflect the value we give each smart speaker, there is and will always be a level of subjectivity to each review. If your experience with a smart speaker differs from ours, we'd love to hear from you.
We review the speakers as we get them and software updates and improvements can occur after the time of review, changing the performance of the device. Where possible, we will strive to reflect these updates in our reviews.
More smart speaker articles
Google's 2nd generation Nest Hub can track your sleep, work with Thread-compatible home network gear, and it's now even more affordable.Read more…
Google's Nest Audio delivers great sound output for a smart speaker in its price range.Read more…
If you're already heavily in the Alexa ecosystem, the Echo Auto makes it simple enough to get it running in your car – but it's beset with a lot of software bugs that make it distinctly second-rate.Read more…
More guides on Finder
Finder Daily Deals: The 5 best online deals in Australia today
Today's best Finder Daily deals include: $1,250 off electric bikes, $70 off Nintendo Switch, $30 off Logitech G PRO X Lightspeed headsets.
AMD RX 6700 XT review
The Radeon RX 6700 XT is a powerful 1440p graphics card that bridges the gap between Nvidia's RTX 3060 Ti and RTX 3070.
We'll show you how to compare mascara brands and products to get the lashes you’ve been dreaming of.
Jura E8 review
The new 2021 Jura E8 has an upgraded grinder, automatic milk cleaning feature and can make your favourite drinks using voice commands.
Razer Huntsman V2 Analog gaming keyboard review
Fast, versatile and robust, the Razer Huntsman V2 Analog is a top-tier gaming keyboard through and through, but its analogue switches aren't as revolutionary as they might have been.
Best wine clubs and subscription services in Australia
We’ve done the hard work to find the best wine clubs and subscription services for Australian wine drinkers.
Best bassinets in Australia
These are the 8 best bassinets you can buy right now in Australia.
2021 Kia Stinger 330S review
The Kia Stinger 330S costs $9,800 less than the top of the line GT model. But should you buy it?
Lenovo ThinkVision T24i-20 Review: A monitor for the business basics
Lenvovo’s ThinkVision T24i-20 is a business-first monitor with a rotating display and just a few key extra features.
Google Nest Hub 2nd Generation Review: While you were sleeping
Google’s Nest Hub benefits from better sound and Thread compatibility, but the much-hyped sleep tracking is too erratic to be truly trustworthy.
Ask an Expert