We’re reader-supported and may be paid when you visit links to partner sites. We don’t compare all products in the market, but we’re working on it!
Best Rated Sandwich maker Brand: Breville
Breville is synonymous with toasted sandwiches, so it's unsurprising it has won this category for the second year in a row. The brand was most recommended overall and also scored well for durability.
Quick facts about comparing sandwich makers
- When choosing a sandwich press, one of the most important factors to consider is the size of the press.
- You'll also need to think about how easy it is to clean and how much you want to spend.
- Prices range from less than $10 up to around $100.
Compare sandwich makers
What is a sandwich maker?
Also known as a sandwich maker, sandwich toaster, sandwich grill or jaffle maker, a sandwich press is a standard appliance in many kitchens. When buying a sandwich maker, you'll find products from a range of major small appliance manufacturers, including Sunbeam, Breville, Russell Hobbs, Tefal and DeLonghi.
Types of sandwich makers
There are a few different types of sandwich makers available including toasted sandwich makers, panini presses and grills.
- Toasted sandwich makers. These appliances are designed for conventionally shaped slices of bread. They can keep all your ingredients in the bread and minimise mess, but don't work well with different types of bread (eg baguettes) or super-sized sandwiches.
- Sandwich and panini presses. Designed to handle bread in a variety of shapes and sizes, sandwich presses allow you to cook larger sandwiches between two non-stick grilling surfaces. They're practical for cooking a wide range of bread-based treats, but because they don't seal off your sandwich the cooking process may be a little messier.
- Multi-use grills. Some sandwich presses are also designed to handle a variety of other kitchen tasks, such as grilling meat and veggies or making waffles.
How to compare sandwich makers
To ensure you choose the best sandwich maker for your needs, you'll need to consider the type of toasted sandwiches you want to make and how much money you're willing to spend.
For example, if you just want to make simple grilled cheese toasties, a cheap, entry-level machine will offer what you need. But if you plan on crafting a wide range of sweet and savoury toasted delights for your family, you might need something more advanced.
You can pick up a basic sandwich maker for less than $20. Most models will cost anywhere between $20 and $100. As you'd expect, four-slice models cost more than those that can only handle two slices. Multi-use grills that are capable of cooking meat, vegetables, waffles and pancakes typically cost $100 or more.
Sandwich makers can typically make one, two or four sandwiches at the same time. Larger models can usually handle more bread types and shapes, such as focaccias or baguettes. However, don't forget to consider the amount of kitchen benchtop space your sandwich maker will take up.
Ease of cleaning
Sandwich makers typically feature a non-stick coating to ensure easy cleaning, while some models come with removable, dishwasher-friendly plates. If choosing a sandwich press, consider whether it has flat or ribbed grill plates and whether this will affect how simple it is to clean.
Consider how much space you have in your kitchen cupboards to store your sandwich maker. Is cord storage integrated into the base of the appliance? Can you lock your sandwich toaster shut so that it can be stored vertically if needed?
Many models will allow you to adjust the height of the top plate and lock it in at varying levels to suit the size of the sandwich you're making. However, this may not be available on entry-level appliances.
If you're choosing a sandwich maker that seals off the edges of your bread and slices it into triangles, check whether the pockets in the machine are deep enough to hold all the fillings you plan on stuffing into your sandwiches.
Most sandwich makers include indicator lights to let you know when they're turned on and when they've heated to optimum temperature. Some more advanced models feature adjustable temperature controls to allow you to cook sandwiches and other foods exactly how you want.
If you're the type of toastie maker who can't stand waiting for their gourmet creation to be ready, some models come with a countdown timer.
Most products come with a warranty of one or two years, but it's worth checking the fine print to find out how long the warranty runs for and exactly what it covers.
Best rated sandwich maker brand award breakdown
|Overall rating||Value for money||Durability||Ease of cleaning||Performance|
Previous Retail Awards
More guides on Finder
Best ice cream makers in Australia
These are the best ice cream makers available to buy in Australia right now.
Pasta maker Finder: Take the effort out of DIY pasta making
If you’re searching for the perfect pasta maker, here’s how to compare your options before you buy.
Best juicers in Australia
These are the 6 best centrifugal and cold-press juicers you can buy online in Australia right now.
Gardening tools: How to compare hand and power tools
Your guide to the essential gardening tools you need to keep your garden in shape and how to choose the best garden tools for your needs.
Compare electric blankets: How to choose between fitted, non-fitted and throw styles
Learn about the different types and features of electric blankets and how you can keep your family safe while staying warm.
Compare linen and bedding: How to buy the right sheets and doonas
How to compare all the bedding options to find the best kind for a perfect night’s sleep.
Compare cordless drills: How to choose the right model for your needs
We’ll help you choose the perfect cordless drill to add to your toolbox and tackle DIY projects at home.
Compare barrel vacuum cleaners: How to find the right model for your home
Learn how to choose the best barrel or canister vacuum cleaner for your home.
Robot vacuum cleaner Finder: How to find the right model for your floors
Learn how to choose the best robot vacuum cleaner for your home size and floor type.
Compare ovens: Your guide to choosing the right oven for your kitchen
What you need to know about wall and freestanding ovens to find the best oven for your kitchen.
Ask an Expert