8 non-touristy things to do in NYC | A couple of travel makers | Finder

8 non-touristy things to do in NYC | A couple of travel makers

What to do and where to be that's (practically) crowd-free.

We’re reader-supported and may be paid when you visit links to partner sites. We don’t compare all products in the market, but we’re working on it!

So you've been welcomed by the Statue of Liberty, re-lived the final scene of Sleepless in Seattle on top of the Empire State Building, shopped like Carrie Bradshaw down 5th and Madison and caught a show on Broadway. Now what?

Whether you've exhausted the icons or you're searching for a unique experience of The Big Apple, we spent our last New York trip uncovering the spaces and experiences where you're less likely to find snap-happy tourists and more likely to enjoy the city like a local.

Here's our shortlist:

Picture not described

We're Stef and D, a pair of married jet setters. Together, we've visited over 50 countries, and we're determined to see even more – all while working full time and paying off a mortgage. We count our dollars at home and while away and are here to share our tips on how you can travel on a budget.

New blog posts every fortnight on Mondays. Follow us: @acoupleoftravelmakers

1. See the city from Brooklyn Heights

Picture not described

While we won't deny you the achingly beautiful view of the city from the Statue of Liberty Ferry, if you're seeking an inexpensive or more unique point of view, head to Brooklyn Heights.

As it's located south of the Brooklyn Bridge, not too many tourists make the hike. Those who do are greeted by a tree-lined promenade that boasts picture-perfect views of lower Manhattan and the Statue of Liberty.

Numerous parks and green spaces speckle the walkway and are often filled with locals on the weekends. As the area is quite serene, it's ideal for a stroll for two.

New York travel tip:

If you're keen on a closer view of the Statue of Liberty, but aren't thrilled by the queue or the cost, then take the Staten Island Ferry. It's free to ride and sails right past her. The only negative is that it doesn't stop at the island itself.

2. Catch live comedy at Comedy Cellar or UCB

Picture not described

Picture not described

Now you can catch a show on Broadway or be part of a live audience, but if you'd prefer to veer away from the norm, comedy is the way to go.

The most popular shows can be found at the Comedy Cellar. Big-name acts who have tread its boards include Ray Romano, Chris Rock, Amy Schumer and Damon Wayans, so you never know which rising star you might witness before their big break. You don't have to really plan this one, as multiple shows play every evening. They're priced from US$14 to $US$22, plus a mandatory two-item minimum food or drink purchase per person. Make a night of it.

For something a little more low key, try the UCB Theatre in Hell's Kitchen. Again, shows run every night and you don't have to pre-book. We rocked up for an evening of live improv with SNL's writers 30 minutes before the gig and had no issues getting in. The crowd here is very much local or "in the biz" and tickets start from US$7 with no mandatory food or drink purchases.

3. Walk the High Line to Hudson Yards

Picture not described

This is hands down my (Stef's) favourite experience in New York. Truth be told, it is a tourist attraction, but it's also a local haunt, so we're keeping it on this list.

Essentially, it's a freight rail line that's been repurposed into a garden and art walkway. You'll find it running along the western edge of Manhattan from Gansevoort Street to the redeveloped "billionaires playground" of Hudson Yards.

Along the 2.33km walk are gardens, resting spaces, street viewing areas, cafes, art installations and graffiti walls. At a stroll, it'll take you about an hour. If you'd prefer a more immersive experience, you can always join a walking tour.

4. Attend a book tour or live gig

Whether you're a book geek or a music maven, New York is the place to fangirl/boy your heart out with your favourite writer/musician/actor. Particularly, ones that haven't (and most likely won't) make it to Australian shores anytime soon.

While in town, D caught Randall Munroe debuting his latest dictionary-sized read How To, while Stef got her inner country on by catching Sister Hazel at a venue near Broadway.

Whatever your desire, you should organise this one before you land, as these are mostly ticketed events. We like Bandsintown for a head's up on the acts visiting during your stay.

5. Eat, drink and check out the city from Williamsburg

Picture not described

North of the Brooklyn Bridge, on the Brooklyn side of the city, is where you'll discover Williamsburg. It's a hipster base with trendy rooftop bars, boujee cafes, quality coffee and modern apartments and buildings overlooking the Manhattan skyline.

Unlike Brooklyn Heights, lady liberty is out of sight from Williamsburg, however, you can still capture the Empire State Building and the Chrysler Building from here.

On the plus side, being a developed area, the promenade is wider and more inviting compared to that of Brooklyn Heights. And, being inconveniently placed away from attractions, it's also a much quieter spot to hang out and relax in.

6. Eat at Smorgasburg

Picture not described

One of the best ways to eat and explore like a local is by hitting up the markets. And one of the most popular is Williamsburg's Smorgasburg.

Hosted primarily on the weekends, this food-stall haven has grown so rapidly it's now held in several locations across the city.

While Williamsburg is the original, if your plans are elsewhere, you can tuck into the local gastronomy at Prospect Park in Breeze Hill Brooklyn (pictured) or outside the World Trade Centre in the CBD.

7. Explore Flushing/Queens

Picture not described

From the Unisphere made famous by Men in Black to the US Open and the locally lauded Chinatown, Queens is the underrated district that you should make the effort to visit.

Because, you know, most tourists don't.

The atmosphere is bustling and honestly, it has more going for it than you think. For the curious, there's the New York Hall of Science, Queens Zoo and Westinghouse Time Capsules. For the hungry, you can opt to eat the authentic dumplings and bubble tea in Flushing Chinatown. You won't regret it.

New York travel tip:

I hate to sound like a broken record, but if you're in town for the US Open, then book your tickets early. We only discovered that our dates aligned a month out from our travels, so we were stuck purchasing resale tickets and, as you can see below, they weren't the closest seats you can get. They also cost us US$300 (ouch!), though bear in mind that we were at the Women's Finals.

Picture not described

8. Discover the world of slam poetry

Bred out of Chicago, slam poetry – or spoken word – is a relatively modern art form that takes poetry and turns it into performance. It could be as simple as an engaging read or as magical as a musical performance.

Select venues around the Big Apple host performances and competitions throughout the week. The Bowery and the Nuyorican are both spaces renowned for slam poetry that we highly recommend. They're intimate, relaxed and – because slam poetry hasn't received heavy traction worldwide yet – aren't usually hit by tourists.

How much money do I need in New York?

Here's a breakdown of what we spent on our trip over a week to give you an idea of how much you should set aside. We stayed cheap in an Airbnb but splurged on experiences such as a steak lunch at Peter Luger and finals tickets to the US Open.

  • Bus ride: $18.74 (Philadelphia to New York City via Megabus)
  • Internal transport: US$86
  • Accommodation: $1,190.35 (Airbnb)
  • Meals and drinks: US$744.23
  • Activities and experiences: US$794.32 (US Open tickets, MET tickets, Natural History Museum tickets, Central Park Zoo tickets, concert tickets, Broadway musical and book tour entry)
  • Other: US$254.26
  • Annual leave days taken: 6

Total for 8 days/7 nights for two people: $3,948.48

The latest New York City travel deals


Up to 60% off activities, experiences and things to do

Valid on select dates including holidays like Christmas, New Year's and more depending on the destination. Destinations include Hong Kong, Singapore, Osaka, Taipei, Dubai, Sydney, Melbourne, London, Paris, New York and more. T&Cs apply.

Last verified

New York PassNew York Pass

Up to 50% off New York attractions

Get a Go New York pass and receive up to 50% off attractions. Includes bus tours, sightseeing and more. T&Cs apply.

Last verified


Flights to USA from $484 return

Available on select flight dates to Los Angeles, San Francisco, Hawaii, New York, Las Vegas and more. Sample fare is Sydney-Honolulu with Jetstar.

Last verified

Deal ends

Millennium & Copthorne HotelsMillennium & Copthorne Hotels

Up to 30% off + receive 2,000 Bonus My Points on USA getaways

Plus get up to 20% off dining and kids stay free on stays until 31 December 2021. Destinations include New York, Los Angeles and more. T&Cs apply

Last verified

Deal ends

Accor HotelsAccor Hotels

Up to 25% off advance purchase

Available on select dates when you book 7+ days in advance. Destinations include Melbourne, London, France, New York, Brazil and more. T&Cs apply.

Last verified

More guides on Finder

Ask an Expert

You are about to post a question on finder.com.au:

  • Do not enter personal information (eg. surname, phone number, bank details) as your question will be made public
  • finder.com.au is a financial comparison and information service, not a bank or product provider
  • We cannot provide you with personal advice or recommendations
  • Your answer might already be waiting – check previous questions below to see if yours has already been asked

Finder only provides general advice and factual information, so consider your own circumstances, or seek advice before you decide to act on our content. By submitting a question, you're accepting our Terms of Use, Disclaimer & Privacy Policy and Privacy & Cookies Policy.
Go to site