Compare manual coffee machines: How to find the perfect coffee maker

Find out if a manual coffee machine suits your coffee drinking habits, budget and lifestyle.

Last updated:

Man and woman drinking coffee on a couch in their living room

Quick facts about manual coffee machines

  • Manual coffee machines can make intense, full-bodied coffee with freshly ground coffee beans.
  • They are more time-demanding and higher maintenance that other coffee machines, but they offer greater flexibility and total control over the end product.
  • The price of a manual coffee machine can vary greatly from about $89 to over $1,799 depending on the brand and range of functions.

Compare manual coffee machines

Updated November 19th, 2019
Name Product Capsule Type Product Dimensions Product More info
De'Longhi La Specialista Coffee Machine ECP9335M
None
375mm x 368mm x 445mm
Delonghi EC685W Dedica Pump Espresso Coffee Machine
ESE Pod
330mm x 149mm x 303mm
Smeg ECF01BLAU38508-340 50's Retro Style Espresso Coffee Machine With Barista Pack
ESE Pod
330mm x 149mm x 303mm
Smeg ECF01CRAU38508-340 50's Retro Style Espresso Coffee Machine With Barista Pack
ESE Pod
330mm x 149mm x 303mm
Delonghi ECO310R Icona Pump Espresso Coffee Machine
ESE Pod
290mm x 260mm x 315mm

Compare up to 4 providers

How do manual coffee machines work?

Manual coffee machines are designed for coffee enthusiasts and professional baristas looking for a practical, hands-on experience who want to experiment with their coffee and make their own cup from scratch.

With a manual coffee machine, there are several extra steps you need to take before making your cup of coffee including picking your own beans, grinding them to your desired level of fineness and filling them into the machine's portafilter and tamping them evenly.

Once you've filled the exact amount of ground coffee you want into the group head, you set the machine to pour. The difference between a manual and a semi-automatic coffee machine is that, at this point, the semi-automatic machine will automatically stop the flow of coffee once your cup is filled to a certain pre-set amount, whereas the manual machine needs you to manually control the temperature and pressure of the water as it mixes through the ground coffee and stop the flow yourself.

Complete coffee novices may want to think twice before investing in a manual coffee machine.

If that's you or you're just unsure whether a manual coffee machine is the right fit for your home or office, read more about the full range of coffee machines available in our guide to the best coffee machines here.

How to compare manual coffee machines

Before deciding on your chosen manual coffee machine, consider the following key features:

Taste

While you'll be able to customise the flavour of your coffee with a manual coffee machine, you'll still have to consider whether you enjoy the selected coffee machine's crema colour and thickness, as well as the aroma, flavours, creaminess, wateriness and aftertaste.

Milk frothing quality

Each line of machine will froth the milk slightly differently, but what's important is to consider whether the froth is of a fine and pourable texture. Some machines will use a milk frother, milk-based capsule or coffee capsule with milk poured over it.

Temperature consistency

If you make coffee in large batches, such as in an office or when entertaining, it's important to consider one that has a high temperature consistency score or else you could end up with a disappointing batch of coffee.

Ease of use

In the actual process of making coffee, you also need to ask these questions: are the controls easy to operate, is filling the water tank and the bean hopper simple, is adjusting the grinder straightforward and is the machine easy to clean?

Pump pressure

This is the pressure the pump exerts when pushing water through the ground beans. Look for one with at least 15 bar. Stronger pressure means more of the coffee beans can be extracted into the hot water to produce a fuller-bodied flavour.

Customisability

You can save time with pre-set functions including pre-setting the ground coffee quantity, programming batch coffee and fully adjusting water and milk temperatures. Some more sophisticated models also allow you to set the exact temperature and style of the milk froth.

Size

Manual coffee machines can get quite bulky and space-draining, so it's best to check the dimensions of your chosen model against the kitchen-top space you have available. Decide how much space you'd be willing to sacrifice in exchange for a full-fledged machine. Keep in mind, smaller machines are as powerful.

Filter basket

Filter baskets range in size, type, diameter and depth and can significantly affect the taste and strength of the espresso. If you want to make larger coffees or batch brews, look for a commercial-sized filter basket.

Recycling

While capsule coffee manufacturers often have their own recycling scheme, this isn't the case for coffee beans. For those who are environmentally friendly, you may want to research any local composting services that collect coffee grounds.

Heat-up and frothing times

It's important to consider how efficient and quick the machine is to heat up and froth milk as this can considerably affect how your final cup of coffee turns out.

Capacity

Check the volume of the drip tray and water tank. A bigger capacity means you'll spend far less time refilling and maintaining your coffee machine, which could help mitigate the time you spend grinding coffee beans.

Warranty

Ideally, opt for a model with a warranty of at least six months to one year, particularly for a more costly manual coffee machine.

What to watch out for

Here's a quick checklist of what to watch out for when choosing your manual coffee machine:

  • Grinder. Is there an in-built grinder attached to the coffee machine?
  • Compactness. How large is the machine and can it accommodate a large cup easily?
  • Filter basket. What kind and size of filter basket is included and is it compatible with the machine?
  • Drip tray. Is it removable and does it come with a full display indicator?
  • Cup-warming plate. Does your chosen model come with a cup-warming plate?
  • Controls. Are the screen and buttons well-illuminated and easy to read?
  • Digital reminders. If you want to get reminded to refill the water tank, double check your model has this feature as not all coffee machines do.
  • Finish. What is the finish of the machine like? While stainless steel machines look good when first purchased, they are particularly difficult to clean and can leave fingerprint marks all over.

Was this content helpful to you? No  Yes

Related Posts

Ask an Expert

You are about to post a question on finder.com.au:

  • Do not enter personal information (eg. surname, phone number, bank details) as your question will be made public
  • finder.com.au is a financial comparison and information service, not a bank or product provider
  • We cannot provide you with personal advice or recommendations
  • Your answer might already be waiting – check previous questions below to see if yours has already been asked

Finder only provides general advice and factual information, so consider your own circumstances, or seek advice before you decide to act on our content. By submitting a question, you're accepting our Terms of Use, Disclaimer & Privacy Policy and Privacy & Cookies Policy.
Ask a question
Go to site