IOTA prices drop on BlackHat, internal drama leak, Sirin Labs departure
There are exactly three and a half reasons why IOTA prices are falling so hard today.
Cryptocurrencies are typically built around decentralised communities, so community management is a key skill in the toolbox of most prominent cryptocurrency leaders – not that they theoretically have leaders.
It's also a very responsive market with coin prices quickly rolling up and down based on the mood of the market. The mood soured on IOTA today, with prices at the time of writing dropping over 15% in 24 hours against the US dollar, or about 10% against BTC and ETH. There are several goods reasons for the drop.
Three and a half reasons why
There are three potential reasons for the drop today:
- Today's presentation of supposed IOTA vulnerabilities at the BlackHat hacking conference
- Leaked internal discussions showing tensions running high within the IOTA Foundation
- Sirin Labs has parted ways with IOTA.
It's also worth noting that IOTA prices have run much lower on Bitfinex than other markets, leading some to suggest an element of manipulation.
The lowdown: BlackHat
The BlackHat presentation promised to deliver a demonstration of a practical attack on IOTA from security researchers Neha Narula and Ethan Heilman.
In the months leading up to the presentation, IOTA developers were quite concerned, as evidenced from the internal leak (more on that below), with security researchers suggesting that the presentation would include an unwelcome surprise and showcase vulnerabilities that may have been overlooked by the IOTA Foundation.
But in the end, it was just a benign rehashing of old information.
The short version is as follows:
- IOTA contracted Narula and Heilman as security researchers to look for vulnerabilities.
- They came back saying they found a vulnerability.
- IOTA publicly announced that there was a potential vulnerability and immediately implemented the recommended fix.
- After further investigation, IOTA determined that the vulnerability wasn't as severe as initially thought.
- Narula and Heilman disagreed and accused IOTA of covering themselves and trying to silence security research, while IOTA accused Narula and Heilman of dishonestly acting on conflicts of interest due to their competing project.
- Today, Narula and Heilman maintain that they discovered a dangerous problem that IOTA fixed on their recommendations. This was the angle presented at BlackHat. IOTA maintains that there was never a problem and that Narula and Heilman are competitors trying to sabotage IOTA for financial gain.
At first it was a he said she said situation, but a few months later, an unknown person hacked Narula's work email and leaked the full exchange.
The full details are highly technical and anyone who can decipher it probably has better things to do than decipher it, but a sniff test comes out strongly in IOTA's favour.
The main takeaway is that IOTA was fully forthcoming and openly announced the supposed vulnerability to the world as soon as it was reported. It was only later, after more thorough investigation, that they concluded it wasn't actually a vulnerability. Narula and Heilman are essentially accusing IOTA of trying to cover something up by publicly announcing it, which doesn't make a whole lot of sense. Other factors also point to IOTA being in the right.
The skinny: New IOTA leak
The recent internal leak from the IOTA Foundation might be much more deeply concerning than the rumours being rehashed at BlackHat. The gist is as follows:
- Linchpin IOTA developer Sergey Ivancheglo (aka Come From Beyond) announced that he doesn't trust IOTA Foundation head Dominik Schiener, and posted a bunch of chat logs along with his declaration, revealing some internal disagreements.
- The disagreement centred around Ivancheglo and Serguei Popov not being official members of the IOTA Foundation Board of Directors and not having formal voting rights within the organisation despite being integral to the project.
- Shortly afterwards, the IOTA Foundation released an official statement, and Ivancheglo withdrew his announcement, describing it as an emotional overreaction to a situation that didn't feel fair.
The reason given for Ivancheglo and Popov not being board members is basically that the IOTA Foundation is formally registered as a non-profit foundation in Germany, and changes to the board or the Foundation's constitution can't be done as easily as just snapping one's fingers. By simply appointing Ivancheglo and Popov to the board in the way that Ivancheglo wanted, the foundation might end up liable for back taxes on its IOTA holdings and sales. That would be bad.
These details were lost on Ivancheglo who didn't get what the hold up was and who had already issued a kind of "do it now or I'll publish these chat logs" ultimatum to Dominik Schiener, who had stepped away from his computer.
The entire situation brings back doubts about the maturity of the team behind IOTA, and their ability to handle what turned into a very high profile multi-billion dollar enterprise. Although, as the logs show, foundation member Ralf Rottmann proved to be something of a levelling influence next to the volatile temperaments of some of the other board members.
But it's also worth noting that towards the end, Rottmann suggested that there might be some other skeletons in the closet.
"The public will ultimately judge on their own. Just thinking about *all of the other stuff* that will come to light, makes me extremely worried," he wrote.
"But we are all grown ups," he finished, despite all evidence to the contrary.
The rundown: Sirin Labs and IOTA part ways
The least impactful news might be that Sirin Labs, creator of the world's first blockchain smartphone - the Finney - stepped away from IOTA a couple of days ago. Its original plan was to use the IOTA network for its phone, but so far IOTA just isn't ready for prime time even as the Finney is about to enter production. Sirin Labs will be using the Ethereum network instead.
Having good reasons for falling prices is a refreshing change.
Disclosure: At the time of writing, the author holds ETH, IOTA, ICX, VET, XLM, BTC and ADA.
- Ethereum price: Upward surge noted but fears of near-term volatility continue to persist
- Can Anchorage bring crypto staking and DeFi to banks?
- Bitcoin price crashed after touching US$42,000 – and that’s okay
- Bitcoin price hits US$40,000 again before meeting resistance
- Bitcoin price: Strong gains may put new all-time highs in reach