Finder to the Node: No speed guidelines for fixed wireless NBN any time soon
Fixed wireless woes
Back in 2017, the ACCC laid out a set of guidelines for Aussie broadband providers designed to clear up confusion around the capabilities of their fixed-line NBN services. These guidelines called for the clear display of the typical speeds offered on fixed-line NBN services during the hours of 7:00pm to 11:00pm, the period when network congestion typically has the biggest impact on Internet performance.
In the two years since the ACCC's recommendations, most Aussie telcos have shifted to this new model of advertising, making it considerably easier for customers to compare the quality of service each telco offers.
Unfortunately, Aussies shopping for a fixed wireless NBN plan haven't been so lucky. The original ACCC guidelines focused on fixed-line services exclusively, allowing telcos to continue advertising their fixed wireless services on the basis of their NBN speed tiers. It was only in November 2018 that the consumer watchdog issued an update regarding similar guidelines for fixed wireless services. However, this time around the response from the broadband industry hasn't been quite so favourable.
At the tail end of 2018, the representative body Communications Alliance submitted a response to the ACCC's updated guidelines. Formed by members from all corners of the telecommunications industry, Communications Alliance serves as a solid barometer for how the various parties involved in Australia's broadband market feel about issues like instituting speed guidelines for fixed wireless NBN services. In this case, the sentiment was distinctly negative.
"Expanding the fixed line speed Guidance to fixed wireless services is not appropriate," reads the response. "It will cause confusion for consumers, and possibly put RSPs [telcos] in the impossible position of either abiding by the Guidance but not complying with the ACL (by providing peak speeds information that is not reliable), or complying with the ACL by only providing reliable information, but contradicting the Guidance."
The response goes on to detail how fixed wireless technology is, by its very nature, more prone to variability than a fixed-line service. Interference from other wireless signals, physical obstructions and changes in weather can cause speeds on fixed wireless to fluctuate wildly, with users in different locations likely to experience notably different performance. According to Communications Alliance, this makes it nigh impossible to provide an accurate "typical evening speed" for a fixed wireless service, as multiple consecutive tests could have completely different results.
Ultimately, Communications Alliance disagrees with the ACCC's proposed guidelines and suggests instead that more effort be directed to educating consumers about the variable nature of fixed wireless NBN. With the weight Communications Alliance carries in the telecommunications space, it's unlikely we'll see typical evening speeds for fixed wireless NBN any time soon.
Credit for initial reporting goes to IT News.
5G remains a thorn in the NBN's side
At CES 2019 earlier this year, numerous representatives from the smartphone and telecommunications industries promised the world that 2019 will be the year of 5G. If the hype is to be believed, the high-speed wireless network will unlock a plethora of new opportunities in the mobile space, enabling higher-quality video conferences and TV streams on the go as well as delivering faster response times for services operating in the cloud.
Despite the optimism, though, there are still a few hurdles on the path to 5G here in Australia. As reported by the Australian Financial Review, Vodafone has called out NBN Co for hindering the 5G rollout by locking down a chunk of the 5G spectrum. Worse, Vodafone claims most of that chunk is lying dormant, devoid of the fixed wireless traffic NBN Co has reserved it for.
According to Vodafone's chief strategy officer Dan Lloyd, this severely hamstrings the potential of 5G in Australia.
"Ultimately, without access to this additional spectrum, consumers will miss out on earlier access to 5G, better network performance, lower costs and a more competitive 5G market in Australia," Lloyd told AFR.
"While we were pleased to acquire substantial 5G spectrum holdings via the joint venture with TPG at the recent auction, we are concerned there will be far less spectrum available for 5G in Australia than is being made available in most other countries."
However, this isn't how NBN Co sees it. In response to Lloyd's claims, an NBN Co spokesperson told AFR "There is no possibility today of other operators using NBN Co's spectrum assets without risk of interference to nbn fixed wireless subscribers".
Nevertheless, NBN Co claims it is looking into a potential solution for opening up more of the 5G spectrum to network providers like Vodafone. The NBN Co spokesperson said that "NBN Co is working with the industry to investigate possible spectrum interference mitigation techniques".
Need a new broadband plan? You should compare your NBN options. You can compare plan choices based on the NBN technology available at your address in our NBN plan checker.
Finder to the Node is a weekly round-up of all the latest news surrounding Australia's complex National Broadband Network.
- Comparison of the week: NBN vs mobile broadband
- Finder to the Node: Optus hikes prices and Aussies warm to the NBN
- Finder to the Node: Labor and the ACCC weigh in on the future of the NBN
- Finder to the Node: Budget cuts regional NBN subsidies, Vocus cuts NBN Basic plans
- Finder to the Node: Bye-bye to Basic speeds and farewell to MyNetFone