Diesel vs Petrol: A car-buying guide
Wondering whether you'll save in the long run with a diesel purchase? Here's what you need to know to make a decision.
We’re reader-supported and may be paid when you visit links to partner sites. We don’t compare all products in the market, but we’re working on it!
Diesel cars have come a long way in recent years. While petrol may have been obvious ten years ago, the introduction of luxury diesel alternatives and improvements in technology have closed the gap. Want to make the right decision for your next car purchase? The guide below outlines all the variables to factor into your decision.
How much will you save?
The main reason people opt for diesel cars is to save money on fuel. However, because diesel cars are usually a few thousand dollars (10-15%) more expensive than their petrol-alternatives, you need to factor that into your purchase decision. Some car companies claim that diesel vehicles use around 30% less fuel than petrol vehicles. This figure will vary depending on the size of the vehicle and how you drive it and in some cases may be closer to the 15-20% mark.
According to a study by the NRMA Motoring & Services, which compared four vehicles with petrol and diesel variants, the vehicles with diesel used 20% less fuel on average. The highest reduction in fuel consumption was from the Holden Epica by 33%. The lowest was the Hyundai Sonata, which saw a fuel consumption reduction of 13%.
What about performance?
Petrol cars are generally more powerful than diesel. However, power isn't everything. Diesel vehicles can deliver a large amount of torque at low revs, so if you're travelling at 1,500 - 2,500rpm you'll power ahead. This makes diesel better for cruising, whereas petrol cars are better for speed.
Higher servicing costs of diesel cars
Diesel vehicles come with notoriously higher costs for servicing and upkeep. These vehicles need diesel-specific oils, filters and coolants that can come with a higher price-tag. According to an RACQ factsheet, a Hyundai i30 Active petrol costs 5.95c per kilometre in services and repairs, while the diesel costs 6.37c per kilometre. If you look at your fuel savings on that same vehicle, the petrol version will cost you 9.49c per km and you'll pay 6.78c per km for diesel. That's a fuel saving of 28.55%.
If you don't maintain a diesel vehicle you can run into a lot of problems, especially with the engine. Diesel cars are much better for drivers of long distances. A diesel engine, if it conforms to the Euro 5 emission standard, will have a filter built-in, and it's only when the car is driven a certain distance will the filter perform effectively. If it doesn't, you'll be feeling the regret with a sizeable mechanic's bill.
Compare a range of car loan options
Questions to ask before you buy
Would you buy the vehicle for that price regardless of the future costs saving?
If you're willing to pay the cost for the car you're getting based on its features and performance, then you're likely to be happy with it as a diesel vehicle.
Are you buying a new or used vehicle?
Diesel vehicles need to be properly maintained over their lifetime to avoid any major mechanical and engine issues. If you're buying secondhand you'll need to make sure it has no problems before you make your purchase.
How far do you drive?
As mentioned in the guide above, how far you drive has an effect on a diesel car's upkeep. If you're driving less than the national average of 15,000 km per year, or eight to ten km per day, then you may not see the fuel savings you're expecting and you may actually be worse off.
Have you secured your finance?
Remember the initial upfront costs may be higher so compare your options before you go car-hunting. Many lenders offer pre-approval so you know how much you have to spend before you buy your car. You can also consider a car loan broker that can find the loan for you.
More guides on Finder
2021 Kia Stinger 330S review
The Kia Stinger 330S costs $9,800 less than the top of the line GT model. But should you buy it?
Six of the best electric cars in Australia
Here are some of the best electric cars in Australia in 2021.
Toyota RAV4 car loans
Compare car loans and discover prices and specs of the Toyota RAV4.
Dubbo Zoo review: Is it worth it with kids?
Finder's Dubbo Zoo review was conducted by a family of five, including three kids under ten. Is it any good?
Back to the future: 45% of Australians would consider buying an electric car
Australia’s interest in electric cars is accelerating according to new research by Finder, Australia’s most visited comparison site.
How to find the best car storage facility to keep your set of wheels safe and secure.
Car-ching: Ute and SUV drivers are spending an extra $4,500 each year
Australians could be paying thousands of dollars more than necessary to keep their car running, according to new research by Finder, Australia’s most visited comparison site.
2021 Kia Carnival review
Kia's all-new 2021 Carnival people-mover is styled like an SUV. Read our review here.
Upcoming hybrid and electric car comparison
Compare soon-to-launch electric and hybrid cars.
Mercedes-Benz E-Class car insurance
Find out how much the average Mercedes-Benz E-Class costs to insure, as well as how to find a prestige car insurer.
Car Loan OffersImportant Information*
You'll receive a fixed rate of 4.99% p.a.
A low minimum borrowing amount of $2,000 that you can use to purchase a new car or one up to two years old.
You'll receive a fixed rate of 4.69% p.a.
Take advantage of a competitive rate, pre-approval and no early repayment fees when you finance a car under two years old.
You'll receive a fixed rate from 4.99% p.a.
A larger loan of $5,000 or more to help you buy a new or used car. 5-hour pre approval available and no ongoing fees.
You'll receive a fixed rate of 4.99% p.a.
Purchase a new or used car up to 2 years old and benefit from a fixed rate and no monthly fees. Pre-approval available within 5 business hours.
Ask an Expert