Contractor vs employee: Pros and cons

Most of us don’t get a choice, but if you’re a contractor thinking of becoming an employee, or an employee thinking of becoming a contractor it’s good to know what you’re getting yourself in for.

We’re reader-supported and may be paid when you visit links to partner sites. We don’t compare all products in the market, but we’re working on it!

Tax time can be confusing. It makes you re-think things you know and face things that you’ve got no idea about. It’s also important that you get it right first time, to avoid penalties or delays later on.

One of the major ways that your tax return will vary depends on if you are a contractor or an employee. You should know which you are, and which return type you are filing.

  • Individuals starting from $79*
  • Sole trader starting from $150*
  • Ride sharing tax returns start from $110*

FinTax Group Offer

Qualified to handle your tax and financial needs.

Help you complete your tax return if you have more than one job, or income from other sources such as investments.

Offers a wide range of services from tax advice to business setup and advisory.


Compare our online tax providers below

Name Product Fee for unlimited income items (Wages) Deduction Item Fees Online tax returns
FinTax Group
$0 for up to $1000 of deductions
$65 for an investment property
Australia wide
Lodge individual & company tax returns online or in-person. Fast online form with additional options to complete tax returns for investment properties, sole trader tax and share investments.
Refund Express
$0 when you purchase the $49 income package
Australia wide
Option to pay with your tax refund for an extra fee of $10 for basic returns. Lodge individual & company tax returns. Fast online form & free live chat.
Everest Tax & Business Advisors
Business tax: starting from $250
General deductions: $0
For motor vehicle expenses: $15
Australia wide
A boutique firm that provides personalised experiences for all customers. Ideal option for individuals and small businesses based in Perth.
One Minute Tax
Australia wide
Option to pay with your tax refund for an extra fee of $20. Lodge individual & company tax returns. Fast online form & free live chat. Special offer for business owners: Register your new company for only $499 (includes $488 worth of government fees and $100 cashback into your new business bank account). Click 'Go to site' to find out more. T&Cs apply.
$0 for up to 2 deductions
$29 for additional deductions
Australia wide
Option to pay with your tax refund for an extra fee of $29. Online and in-person tax services for individuals, sole traders and companies.
Hotman & Brown
Business tax: starting from $179
$29 for up to 2 deductions
Additional $29 for extra deductions
Option to pay with your tax refund for an extra fee of $29. Basic tax returns over the phone Australia-wide. In-person individual and business tax returns in Melbourne.
Bennetts Tax & BAS service
finder Exclusive: $5 discount
$0 for all work related deductions
Australia wide
finder Exclusive: $5 discount when you apply for a tax return with Bennetts Tax through finder. Click 'Go to site' and complete the contact form to find out more. Income item fee includes returns on interest, dividends, Superannuation and pension. A flexible option for individuals, sole traders and companies.

Compare up to 4 providers


What is an employee?

An employee is someone who works for a business to perform a specific duty in an open ended, permanent contract. The employee is expected to complete their role and in return their employer will take care of all of the practicalities of employment, including superannuation, payroll tax, sickness and annual leave.

What is a contractor?

Contractors are typically self employed people engaged by a company or individual for a specific task, which they often do for an agreed price and with a pre-arranged time frame. Contractors don’t work for anyone exclusively, but rather work for themselves and as such are responsible for a lot of the duties that an employee may not have.

Why do businesses need employees?

Businesses employees complete tasks that are open ended and constantly required for the running and growth of their business. Most workers are employees of their business. They typically have set hours, set salaries and set bonuses built into their contract. They tend to get superannuation, leave hours and more stability with their contract.

Why do businesses use contractors?

Business use contractors to perform tasks that are only required seasonally or for short periods of time. For example, if a window broke, it would make more sense for a business to contract a glazer to fix the single window, rather than employing one. Businesses may use contractors to cover particularly busy periods, such as shops over Christmas or holidays perks in the summer. A lot of businesses have temporary projects where it would be a lot more cost efficient to use a one-off, contractor.

What are the pros and considerations of employment?

  • Regularity and routine.
  • Salary and benefits.
  • Pension.
  • Tax usually taken from pay-cheques.
  • Not usually possible to set own hours.
  • Set amount of annual leave.
  • Often have to travel to office.

What are the pros of considerations of being a contractor?

  • Can set own hours.
  • Often able to work from home or remotely.
  • Variety of work and hours.
  • No fixed income or benefits.
  • Responsible for own tax and finances.

Which is better?

It isn’t really a case of which is better, or which is worse, it’s usually more a case of which works better for the individual. Some people enjoy the routine and regularity of having employment, while some people prefer the freedom and variety of being self employed.

It’s also important to consider where you are in your life, for example, if you don’t have a family then you may prefer and have the time to be an employee, whereas if you have a young family or other commitments, you may prefer the flexibility of being a contractor.

In summary, it isn’t really about which is better or which is worse, it is more about the type that works better for you and for your industry. Both have positives and negatives, and while one might suit one personality type, others will prefer the other.

Back to top

More guides on Finder

Ask an Expert

You are about to post a question on

  • Do not enter personal information (eg. surname, phone number, bank details) as your question will be made public
  • is a financial comparison and information service, not a bank or product provider
  • We cannot provide you with personal advice or recommendations
  • Your answer might already be waiting – check previous questions below to see if yours has already been asked

Finder only provides general advice and factual information, so consider your own circumstances, or seek advice before you decide to act on our content. By submitting a question, you're accepting our Terms of Use, Disclaimer & Privacy Policy and Privacy & Cookies Policy.

2 Responses

    Default Gravatar
    OlcaCanberraJanuary 19, 2018

    Hello, I would like to ask you, if I can work in Australia like a contractor when I’m not of Australian nationality, I mean can I use the platforms for contractors like freelance-market, is it not possible?

      Avatarfinder Customer Care
      RenchJanuary 19, 2018Staff

      Hi Olca,

      Thanks for your inquiry.

      Yes, you can work in Australia as a Contractor even if you have different nationality. It also depends with the company on where you will apply for on what will be the requirements or eligibility criteria on the job position.

      Best regards,

Go to site