Coinbase is losing some institutional trading division heavyweights
How are Coinbase's institutional offerings doing?
Earlier this month, Coinbase's fifth employee, general manager and vice president Adam White, left Coinbase to become COO at Intercontinental Exchange's Bakkt. It might have started a trend, with one of his recent hires, head of trading Hunter Merghart, now leaving after six months on the job.
According to sources who spoke to CoinDesk, the departure came after building frustration at a lack of roadmap clarity and resources to build out the institutional wing of Coinbase.
All over the place
Coinbase has deliberately written up a strategy of doing it all and becoming the cryptocurrency company across not only consumer buying and selling, but also institutional trading, custody solutions, various cryptocurrency utilities both directly financial and tangentially-related, and anything else it can bend its expertise towards.
But Coinbase might be struggling a little with its institutional offerings. The most prominent institutional flop might be its Coinbase Index, a cryptocurrency bundle aimed at institutional traders who want broad exposure to a range of cryptocurrencies in the space.
But it turns out there weren't too many of those. Suffering below-anticipated demand, Coinbase shut down the Index offering recently.
"I think the investors are not going to want to pick specific winners or losers," said Coinbase president and CEO Asiff Hirji at the launch of Coinbase Index.
It might have been a misguided assumption though. By all appearances, people are going out of their way to consider the pros and cons of the coins they purchase, and there might be something about the "collectible" nature of cryptocurrency that encourages participants to dive deep into individual projects.
Besides, there's already a perfectly good way to get broad exposure to cryptocurrency as an asset class – it's called buying bitcoin.
At about the same time it closed down the Coinbase Index, a near-identical product, the more consumer-grade "Coinbase Bundle" hit the market, which similarly offers a broad range of exposure to some of the top assets in the cryptocurrency world. Or as some might see it, a perfectly good batch of BTC and ETH with little bits of less-wanted BCH and ETC mixed in.
While the Coinbase Index might be down and out, other institutional products, including Coinbase Custody, Coinbase OTC and more, are still up and running. Whether these are successfully catering to a somewhat limited demand in an increasingly competitive market is still a bit unclear.
Coinbase aims to do it all, but that might be hard to fit into a clear roadmap. In particular, goals like having $5 billion in crypto assets under management might be harder to achieve when the value of those crypto-assets keeps sliding.
Disclosure: At the time of writing, the author holds ETH, IOTA, ICX, VET, XLM, BTC and ADA.
- David Kleiman, Hal Finney and others helped create Bitcoin, says Dr Craig Wright
- Bitcoin scores golden cross despite, or because of, manipulation allegations
- Can Monero ever achieve private transactions?
- Phil Wilson: Satoshi Nakamoto was Craig Wright, Dave Kleiman and I
- Hybrid public-private blockchains in the real world – Part 2