Car Insurance Companies

I need car insurance – which company is right for me? Compare car insurance companies and get cover that's right for you.

Comparing the car insurance options available to you is something that you should ideally do once a year when it's time to renew your policy. It’s important to regularly compare car insurance policies simply because things change over time. Your insurer may have lowered its rates or another insurer you looked at may now be offering a discount. If you don’t look at what’s out there, you’ll never know.
Your circumstances could also have changed. You may have gotten married, retired, got out of that dreaded under 26 age bracket, or have a new young driver in the family – all of these circumstances affect the cost of your car insurance.
With that in mind, this guide provides a snapshot of a number of different car insurance providers, to provide you with a cursory understanding of what each one of these car insurance companies offer.

Compare policies on offer from Australian car insurance brands

Rates last updated December 10th, 2016
Details Features
Gold Comprehensive
Gold Comprehensive
Save 25% on Gold Comprehensive when you purchase online.
  • New for old replacement for the earlier of 2 years/40,000kms
  • $850 ($100/day) emergency transport and accomodation
  • Cover for replacement of keys up to $500
Get Quote More info
Comprehensive
Comprehensive
Get comprehensive cover for damage to your car and other people's cars and property.
  • Accidental Damage
  • Fire and theft of car
  • No age restrictions on drivers
  • Any number of drivers
Get Quote More info
Gold Comprehensive
Gold Comprehensive
Up to 25% discount for Gold Comprehensive policies purchased online.
  • New for old replacement for the earlier of 2 years/40,000kms
  • $850 ($100/day) emergency transport and accomodation
  • Cover for personal effects up to $500
  • Up to $1,000 key replacement and lock re-code
Get Quote More info
Comprehensive
Comprehensive
24/7 roadside assistance and up to $20 million in liability cover.
  • 24/7 roadside assistance
  • Comprehensive cover for accidental damage
  • Optional hire car provision up to 14 days
  • Up to $20,000 legal liability optional cover
Get Quote More info
Comprehensive
Comprehensive
Buy online to save 25% off your car insurance policy and receive a free 7" Android tablet.
  • New for old replacement for the earlier of 2 years/40,000kms
  • Online discount of 25%
  • $850 ($100/day) emergency transport and accomodation
  • $1,000 cover for hire vehicle following theft (max 14 days)
Get Quote More info
Comprehensive
Comprehensive
Price beat guarantee for comparable comprehensive policies for drivers aged 25 or older.
  • New for old replacement of your car - 24 months
  • Choice of agreed value of car
  • Third party property damage
  • Theft and malicious damage cover
Get Quote More info
Price Saver (Comprehensive)
Price Saver (Comprehensive)
Up to 25% discount for comprehensive policies purchased online.
  • Repairs with authorised dealers guaranteed
  • New for old replacement for the earlier of 2 years/40,000kms
  • No Fault Accident, no excess
  • Hail SMS alerts
Get Quote More info

Car insurance companies in Australia

1300 Car Insurance

Who are they underwritten by?

1300 Car Insurance is a division of 1300 Group Pty Ltd, run by insurance industry experts.

What do they offer?
  • Gold comprehensive – includes benefits like a third party property damage option, death benefit, theft or damage to child restraints,  personal effects and remote or key replacement.
  • Full comprehensive – includes emergency transport and optional  windscreen excess reduction and No Claim Discount (NCD) protection.
  • Third Party Fire & Theft – includes option of restricted driver discounts and roadside assistance.
  • Third Party – includes option of restricted driver discounts and roadside assistance.
What are the benefits of 1300 Car Insurance?
  • some of the industry’s cheapest prices
  • apply over the phone or online
  • 21-day money back guarantee.

1st for Women Car Insurance

Who are they underwritten by?

Underwritten by Auto & General Insurance Company Ltd.

What do they offer?
  • Comprehensive – comprehensive cover designed with women in mind and offering cheaper rates for women drivers.
What are the benefits of 1st for Women Car Insurance?
  • choice of agreed or market value
  • accident hire car benefit
  • roadside assistance
  • maximum No Claim Discount protection
  • windscreen excess reduction
  • restricted driver discounts
  • variable excess
  • lifetime guarantee on all repairs.

AAMI Car Insurance

Who are they underwritten by?

Australian Associated Motor Insurers Local Limited is part of the Suncorp Group.

What do they offer?
  • Comprehensive – covers damage to your vehicle and damage to third party property.
  • Third Party Property – covers your liability for damage to third party property.
  • Compulsory Third Party (CTP) – covers your liability for personal injury to third parties in the event of an accident.
What are the benefits of AAMI Car Insurance?
  • emergency costs
  • new car for old replacement for two years
  • safe driver rewards
  • accident towing
  • choose your own excess
  • optional extras including roadside assistance, windscreen and glass cover and unlimited hire car.

Allianz Car Insurance

Who are they underwritten by?

Allianz car insurance is part of Allianz Australia Life Insurance Ltd, one of Australia’s largest insurance providers.

What do they offer?
  • Comprehensive – includes a choice of agreed or market value, up to $20 million legal liability and rental car if yours is stolen.
  • Third Party – includes up to $20 million legal liability and up to $3000 for loss or damage caused by the driver of an uninsured vehicle.
  • Third Party Fire & Theft – up to $5,000 for loss or damage by fire or theft, with towing costs included.
What are the benefits of Allianz Car Insurance?
  • guarantee on the workmanship of authorised repairs
  • a range of options including rental car, removal of excess for windscreen and glass damage, protection of maximum No Claim Bonus, driver exclusion discounts and cover for stolen work tools or stock.

Australia Post Car Insurance

Who are they underwritten by?

Australia Post Car Insurance is an authorised representative of Travel Insurance Partners Pty Limited,  underwritten by Great Lakes Reinsurance (UK) PLC.

What do they offer?
  • Gold Comprehensive – includes new car replacement for two years, personal effects cover, damage or theft of child seat/baby capsule, death benefit, replacement of keys/remote and emergency accommodation and transport.
  • Third Party Fire & Theft – includes car hire if yours is stolen, up to $3,000 if your car is damaged by an uninsured driver and discounts for restricted drivers.
  • Third Party Property – includes up to $3,000 if your car is damaged by an uninsured driver and discounts for restricted drivers.
What are the benefits of Australia Post Car Insurance?
  • lifetime guarantee on repairs
  • tailored cover to suit your needs
  • flexible payment options.

Budget Direct Car Insurance

Who are they underwritten by?

Budget Direct Car Insurance is a division of the Budget Insurance group, underwritten by Auto and General Insurance Company Ltd.

What do they offer?
  • Gold Comprehensive – includes new for old replacement for two years, emergency transport and accommodation, personal effects and key replacement and lock re-coding.
  • Comprehensive – includes repairs to the other vehicle when you are at fault, emergency transport and accommodation, a hire car if yours is stolen, personal effects cover, damage to your trailer or caravan, replacement of child seats and keys and remotes and no excess or NCD penalty if the other driver is at fault.
  • Third Party Fire & Theft – includes $3,000 uninsured motorist damage, $20 million legal liability and hire vehicle following theft.
  • Third Party Property – includes $3,000 uninsured motorist damage and $20 million legal liability cover.
What are the benefits of Budget Direct Car Insurance?
  • restricted driver discounts
  • choice of market or agreed value
  • lifetime repairs guarantee
  • optional extras including windscreen excess reduction, roadside assistance, accident hire car benefit and variable excess to reduce the premium.
Rates last updated December 10th, 2016
Details Features
Gold Comprehensive
Gold Comprehensive
Up to 25% discount for Gold Comprehensive policies purchased online.
  • New for old replacement for the earlier of 2 years/40,000kms
  • $850 ($100/day) emergency transport and accomodation
  • Cover for personal effects up to $500
  • Up to $1,000 key replacement and lock re-code
Get Quote More info
Third Party Property
Third Party Property
Optional benefits for restricted driver discounts and roadside assistance.
  • $3,000 uninsured motorist damage*
  • $20 million legal liability cover
  • Flexible payment options
  • After-hours claim helpline
Get Quote More info
Third Party Fire and Theft
Third Party Fire and Theft
Optional benefits for restricted driver discounts and roadside assistance.
  • $3,000 uninsured motorist damage*
  • $20 million legal liability cover
  • $1,000 hire vehicle following theft
  • After-hours claim helpline
Get Quote More info

CGU Car Insurance

Who are they underwritten by?

CGU Car Insurance is issued by CGU Insurance Limited, which distributes insurance in partnership with major banks and credit unions.

What do they offer?
  • Comprehensive – includes new vehicle replacement for up to three years, hire vehicle after theft, vehicle towing, windscreen extension option, personal items cover, re-coding of locks and barrels and $30 million liability cover.
  • Third party fire and theft – includes uninsured motorist damage, $30 million liability cover, vehicle towing, hire vehicle after theft, emergency repairs and re-coding of locks and barrels.
  • Third party property – includes uninsured motorist damage and $30 million liability cover.
What are the benefits of CGU Car Insurance?
  • discount if your car is only driven by two nominated drivers over 25
  • discount if two nominated drivers over 25 drive no more than 10,000 kilometres.

Dodo Car Insurance

Who are they underwritten by?

Dodo Car Insurance is partnered with and underwritten by Auto & General Services.

What do they offer?
  • Comprehensive – includes new car replacement for two years, emergency transport and accommodation, hire vehicle after theft. personal effects cover, damage to a caravan or trailer, no excess or NCD penalty if a third party is at fault,  cover for child seats/baby capsule, debris removal, death benefit and replacement of keys or remote.
  • Third Party Fire & Theft – includes hire vehicle after theft and $3,000 cover for uninsured motorists extension.
  • Third Party Property – includes $3,000 cover for uninsured motorists extension.
What are the benefits of Dodo Car Insurance?
  • choice of agreed or market value
  • optional windscreen excess reduction
  • restricted driver discounts
  • variable excess options
  • lifetime guarantee on repairs
  • up to $20 million legal liability cover
  • option of roadside assistance.

GIO Car Insurance

Who are they underwritten by?

GIO Car Insurance is issued by AAI Limited, trading as GIO, which is a subsidiary of the Suncorp Group.

What do they offer?
  • Platinum – comprehensive cover including lifetime new car replacement, windscreen and window damage and unlimited car hire.
  • Comprehensive – includes four year new for old replacement and cover for accidental loss or damage.
  • Third Party Fire & Theft – includes hire car if yours is stolen and up to $20 million liability cover.
  • Third Party Property – includes hire car if yours is stolen or can’t be driven and up to $20 million liability cover.
What are the benefits of GIO Car Insurance?
  • rewards for not claiming
  • multi-policy discounts
  • family discounts
  • option to increase your excess.

ibuyeco Car Insurance

Who are they underwritten by?

ibuyeco Car Insurance is part of the Budget Insurance Group and underwritten by Auto & General Insurance Company Limited.

What do they offer?
  • Comprehensive – includes 12 months new car replacement, emergency transport and accommodation, hire vehicle after theft, personal effects cover, damage to a trailer and no excess or NCD penalty if the other driver is at fault.
  • Third Party Fire & Theft – includes hire vehicle following theft and $3,000 cover for uninsured motorists extension.
  • Third Party Property – includes $3,000 cover for uninsured motorists extension.
What are the benefits of ibuyeco Car Insurance?
  • all policies include a carbon offset service to offset 100% of your car’s annual CO2 emissions
  • freedom to nominate your preferred repairer
  • lifetime guarantee on repairs
  • choice of agreed or market value
  • optional NCD protection, roadside assistance and windscreen excess reduction
  • restricted driver discounts
  • variable excess.

NRMA Car Insurance

Who are they underwritten by?

NRMA Car Insurance is part of Insurance Australia Group (IAG), an Australian-owned company operating in Australia, New Zealand, the United Kingdom and Asia.

What do they offer?
  • Comprehensive Plus – includes new for new car replacement for two years, cover for modifications, damage from storm, earthquake, fire, flood and explosion, car hire and excess, emergency repairs, towing, tools of trade and windscreen, sunroof and glass replacement.
  • Comprehensive – comprehensive cover including all of the above, with hire car and windscreen as optional extras.
  • Third Party Fire & Theft – includes hire car after theft, hire car excess up to $2,000 and up to $5,000 for damage to your vehicle by an uninsured at fault driver.
  • Third Party Property – includes up to $20 million liability and up to $5,000 for damage to your vehicle by an uninsured at fault driver.
What are the benefits of NRMA Car Insurance?
  • multiple policy discounts
  • cover for anyone who drives your car
  • lifetime guarantee on authorised repairs
  • flexible excess levels
  • fuel-efficient vehicle discount.

Find out more about NRMA car insurance

Ozicare Car Insurance

Who are they underwritten by?

Ozicare Car Insurance is part of the Budget Insurance Group, underwritten by Auto & General Insurance Company.

What do they offer?
  • Comprehensive – includes one year new car replacement, hire car after theft, personal effects, trailer cover and emergency transport and accommodation.
  • Third Party Fire & Theft – includes hire car after theft and up to $3,000 uninsured motorist damage.
  • Third Party – includes up to $3,000 uninsured motorist damage.
What are the benefits of Ozicare Car Insurance?
  • Australian-based call centre
  • lifetime guarantee on repairs
  • flexible payment options.

QBE Car Insurance

Who are they underwritten by?

QBE Car Insurance is part of the QBE Insurance Group, which is one of the largest 20 global insurers and reinsurers, with its head office in Sydney and offices in 38 countries.

What do they offer?
  • Comprehensive – covers anyone driving your vehicle for accident, fire, theft and liability for damage to other cars and property.
  • Comprehensive (preferred driver) – same as comprehensive, but with a discount for preferred drivers (24 and over).
  • Comprehensive (nominated driver) – same as comprehensive, but with a discount for nominated drivers (no more than two).
  • Third Party Fire & Theft – covers fire, theft and third party property.
  • Third Party – covers third party property only.
What are the benefits and optional extras of QBE Car Insurance? 
  • four year new car replacement cover
  • no Claim Bonus protection
  • lifetime No Claim Bonus protection
  • hire car after accident
  • excess-free windscreen & glass protection.

RACQ Car Insurance

Who are they underwritten by?

RACQ is part of RACQ Insurance Limited, which is a wholly owned subsidiary of the Royal Automobile Club of Queensland and provides cover to more than 1.7 million policy holders in Queensland and northern NSW.

What do they offer?
  • Comprehensive – includes hire car after theft, choice of repairer, personal property, baby capsules and child seats, emergency repairs, damage to trailer or caravan, keys and locks, towing and storage and access to Aussie Assist (emergency assistance).
  • Third Party Fire & Theft – includes emergency repairs, towing and storage, uninsured third party cover and a lifetime repair guarantee.
  • Third Party – includes uninsured third party cover and a no claim discount.
What are the benefits of RACQ Car Insurance?
  • variable excess
  • multi-policy discount
  • length of membership discount
  • good driver discount
  • no claim discount
  • security discount.

Real Car Insurance

Who are they underwritten by?

Real Car Insurance is issued by Real Insurance, which is part of The Hollard Group, one of the world’s major insurers.

What do they offer?
  • Comprehensive – includes new for new replacement for one year including on-road costs, personal belongings and emergency accommodation, guaranteed repairs, child safety seats, lock and key replacement and trailer and caravan damage.
  • Pay as you drive – same as comprehensive, with a discount for low kilometre use.
  • Build your own – includes third party property, emergency repairs, towing and emergency transport and accommodation, with the option to add more cover as needed.
  • Third Party Property – includes up to $20 million liability cover and limited uninsured driver protection.
What are the benefits and optional extras of Real Car Insurance?
  • roadside assistance
  • pet cover
  • bicycle cover
  • hire car cover
  • windscreen cover
  • two year new car replacement cover.

Virgin Money Car Insurance

Who are they underwritten by?

Virgin Money Car Insurance is part of the global family of Virgin companies and operates in Australia, UK, USA and South Africa.

What do they offer?
  • Comprehensive – includes a choice of one or two year new for old replacement, a lifetime guarantee on repairs, emergency transport and accommodation, personal items, no fault no excess, trailer damage, NCD protection and the option of roadside assistance.
  • Third Party Fire & Theft – includes a security discount and a hire vehicle after theft.
  • Third Party Property – basic property cover including a lifetime guarantee on repairs.
What are the benefits of Virgin Money Car Insurance?
  • variable excess
  • restricted driver discount
  • no claim discount
  • security discount.

Woolworths Car Insurance

Who are they underwritten by?

Woolworths Car Insurance policies are issued by the Hollard Insurance Company.

What do they offer?
  • Comprehensive – includes one year new for old replacement, choice of agreed value, third party property damage and theft and malicious damage.
  • Make your own – includes one year new for old replacement, towing, trailer and caravan cover, essential repairs, personal property, child safety seats and prams, emergency travel and accommodation, substitute car, locks and keys, transit cover, third party property and theft and malicious damage, with the option to add more benefits as needed.
  • Third Party Property – includes substitute car and uninsured motorist benefit.
What are the benefits of Woolworths Car Insurance?
  • customised policies
  • drive less pay less
  • free roadside assistance for 12 months
  • variable excess.
Rates last updated December 10th, 2016
Details Features
Comprehensive
Comprehensive
Price beat guarantee for comparable comprehensive policies for drivers aged 25 or older.
  • New for old replacement of your car - 24 months
  • Choice of agreed value of car
  • Third party property damage
  • Theft and malicious damage cover
Get Quote More info
Third Party Property Damage
Third Party Property Damage
Price beat guarantee for comparable policies for drivers aged 25 or older.
  • Substitute car cover
  • Uninsured motorist benefit
  • Third party property damage
  • No extra charge for paying monthly
Get Quote More info
Third Party Property, Fire and Theft
Third Party Property, Fire and Theft
Price beat guarantee for comparable policies for drivers aged 25 or older.
  • New for old replacement of car - 24 months
  • Choose agreed value of car
  • Third party property damage
  • Theft and malicious damage cover
Get Quote More info
Back to top

Car insurance tips

There are many ways you can lower your premiums, regardless of which insurer you go with. These include:

  • How does my car affect the cost of my insurance? Your car affects the cost of insurance in various. Choosing a car with less horsepower or one less likely to be stolen will reduce the amount you'll have to pay for car insurance.
  • What happens if I nominate drives? Selecting the nominated drivers option can reduce your insurance premiums as you are saying to your insurer, 'These are the people that can drive my car.'
  • How does excess affect my premium? Increase your excess to lower your premium.
  • I don't drive much, can this help me pay less? Yes, some insurers allow you to select the a low kilometres option.
  • I have an alarm, does that help? Yes, adding security to your vehicle can help you to get a security discount.
  • I already have existing cover with this insurer, is there a discount? Sometimes, many insurers provide a loyalty discount if you have more than one type of insurance with the company.
  • I've had the same insurer for a while and never made a claim, where is my benefit? You may already have a No Claims Bonus discount in place. If you don't, it's time to start looking for another provider.
  • What is the difference between agreed and market value? If you are purely trying to reduce your premiums, insure for market rather than agreed value. However, agreed generally pays out a higher benefit as it is what the car was worth when you bought it, not what the car is currently worth.
  • Does gender affect the cost of insurance? Yes, men pay more in general for car insurance then women. So, if you are a couple, take your insurance out in the female’s name, with the male as a nominated driver.
  • Can I save by buying car insurance online? Yes, most insurers offer discounts if you buy your car insurance online.
Back to top

What to look for in a company

Not all car insurance companies are the same and as well as researching their policies, you should also do some research on the insurer themselves to make sure that if you do make a claim, they will be there to pay it. Things to look for when researching car insurance companies include:

  • What is the companies reputation and financial? Insurers are ranked according to their industry standing and claims record by international ratings agency, Standard & Poor’s.
  • What is the car insurers customer satisfaction levels? Talking friends and family who have had dealings with them can give you an indication of how the insurer treats its customers. Social media can also give you an idea of their reputation.
  • What is the companies transparency like? The companies willingness to provide hard copies of contracts and terms can indicate their level of trustworthiness.
  • How does the company handle claims? Make sure you find an insurer that will walk you through its claims process. Check online for customer reviews, you will find a wealth of information about how happy people have been with their claims and also how they were treated.
Back to top

How are car insurers regulated?

Car insurance companies are regulated by The Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA), which also oversees banks, credit unions, building societies, friendly societies and most superannuation funds. APRA supervises institutions holding around $4.9 trillion in assets for depositors, policyholders and super fund members.

APRA is funded primarily by the financial services industry and its self-proclaimed mission is to establish and enforce prudential standards and practices designed to ensure that financial promises made by institutions are met.

Back to top

I'm not satisfied with my claim, what can I do?

If you make a claim and you are unhappy with the way it is handled, all car insurance companies have a dispute resolution process.

  1. The first step is to talk to the insurer about your concerns.
  2. If your claims consultant and their supervisor are unable to resolve the matter to your satisfaction, the next step is an internal review.The claims manager will refer the matter to the insurer’s Internal Dispute Resolution team, who will review your case.
  3. If you are not happy with their decision, you are then entitled to seek an external review. This may be conducted by independent reviewers under the external dispute resolution scheme administered by the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS). Your insurer will advise you of who to contact in this case.
Back to top

I'm ready to compare policies

Hopefully this article has provided some insight into how car insurance companies operate and a comparison of what policies and benefits they offer. Comparing car insurance policies can be a time consuming task if you have to go from one insurer’s website to the next. This guide hopefully made that task easier by allowing you to quickly review a range of car insurance companies in one place.

Compare policies from Australian car insurance companies

Picture: Shutterstock

Was this content helpful to you? No  Yes

Related Posts

Ask a Question

You are about to post a question on finder.com.au

  • Do not enter personal information (eg. surname, phone number, bank details) as your question will be made public
  • finder.com.au is a financial comparison and information service, not a bank or product provider
  • We cannot provide you with personal advice or recommendations
  • Your answer might already be waiting – check previous questions below to see if yours has already been asked

Disclaimer: At finder.com.au we provide factual information and general advice. Before you make any decision about a product read the Product Disclosure Statement and consider your own circumstances to decide whether it is appropriate for you.
Rates and fees mentioned in comments are correct at the time of publication.
By submitting this question you agree to the finder.com.au privacy policy, receive follow up emails related to finder.com.au and to create a user account where further replies to your questions will be sent.

Ask a question
feedback