Best eyebrow pencils in Australia

We read hundreds of customer reviews to find the 7 best eyebrow pencils you can get in Australia right now.

We’re reader-supported and may be paid when you visit links to partner sites. We don’t compare all products in the market, but we’re working on it!

The best eyebrow pencils in Australia

How did we pick this list?

We selected the eyebrow pencils on this list based on actual customer reviews and ratings on Amazon. For every category, we chose parameters based on our research and identified the products with the highest reviews and ratings within those parameters.

Read more detail on our methodology below.

Best overall eyebrow pencil: NYX Professional Makeup Micro Brow Pencil

Pros

  • Good value for money
  • Comes in eight shades

Cons

  • Some customers said the pencil breaks easily
  • Not waterproof

Price (RRP): $16.95
Amazon pricing: From $13.94

Buy at Amazon
Buy at Catch
Buy at eBay

Why we chose it

Our pick for the best overall eyebrow pencil is the Micro Brow Pencil from NYX Professional Makeup. It has a rating of 4.5 out of 5 stars from over 11,000 Amazon customer reviews.

This mechanical, ultra-thin eyebrow pencil can help draw precise brow strokes that look natural. It also helps create more defined brows by filling in sparse areas. According to the manufacturer, the eyebrow pencil is made from a creamy, high-pigment formula and is vegan. It also comes in eight shades – Taupe, Blonde, Auburn, Chocolate, Ash Brown, Brunette, Espresso and Black.

According to customers, this pencil is versatile. It can help create natural-looking or more defined eyebrows effortlessly. Many reviews said it is easy to use and manipulate because of how skinny the pencil is. Its thinness helps create realistic eyebrow strands. Some customers liked that it comes with a spoolie brush, making it compact and travel-friendly. Others praised the product for being affordable. Many customers also raved about the shade range, mentioning that there is a shade for every hair colour. There were some complaints about the pencil breaking easily due to its thinness. A few customers also said that it's not waterproof but works as an everyday eyebrow product.


Best drugstore eyebrow pencil: Maybelline Brow Ultra Slim Eyebrow Pencil

Pros

  • Has an ultra-slim tip for hair-like strokes
  • Built-in spoolie is soft and helps blend the product easily

Cons

  • Some customers said the formula isn't creamy
  • Not suitable for people with sparse brows

Price (RRP): $12.78
Amazon pricing: From $9.60

Buy at Amazon
Buy at Catch
Buy at eBay

Why we chose it

If you're looking for the best drugstore eyebrow pencil available in Australia right now, we recommend Maybelline's Brow Ultra Slim Eyebrow Pencil. On Amazon, it has a rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars from over 4,000 reviews.

The Ultra Slim Eyebrow Pencil is created with a smooth and break-resistant formula, according to the company. It features a slim 1.5mm tip and a built-in spoolie brush for easier application. You can use this pencil to create precise, hair-like strokes for natural-looking eyebrows. It comes in six shades, ranging from light blonde to black.

A lot of customers loved the slim tip of the pencil, allowing them to create natural eyebrows perfect for an everyday look. Others said it's good value for money and comparable to high-end eyebrow pencils they have tried. A few reviews said the built-in spoolie brush is quite soft and helps blend the product seamlessly. Many customers also praised the shade range, mentioning the lighter shades don't have any green tinge which is typical of some eyebrow pencils. However, a few reviews criticised the product's formula, saying it's not creamy enough to create more defined eyebrows. Others also said it's not ideal if you have sparse brows.


Best high-end eyebrow pencil: Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz

Pros

  • Comes in 12 shades
  • Suitable for both natural and defined eyebrows

Cons

  • Not cheap
  • Spoolie brush is stiff

Price (RRP): $37.48
Amazon pricing: From $38.00

Buy at Amazon
Buy at eBay
Buy at Cult Beauty

Why we chose it

For the best high-end eyebrow pencil, we chose Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz. It has a rating of 4.7 out of 5 stars from more than 2,000 Amazon customer reviews.

Brow Wiz is an ultra-thin, retractable eyebrow pencil perfect if you want to outline and detail your brows. According to the company, it has a unique wax formula featuring the perfect blend of eyebrow colour and wax for a high colour payoff. The formula also helps create natural-looking texture and the appearance of fuller brows. This eyebrow pencil comes in 12 shades, ranging from blonde to ash brown. It is also cruelty-free and vegan.

This eyebrow pencil is a cult favourite, with many customers raving about its versatility. They said the product can be used to create natural-looking or thicker, more defined eyebrows. Some customers raved about its ultra-slim tip, mentioning that it is easy to use on-the-go. Others loved the formula, saying it lasts all day even through a sweaty workout. Several customers found the spoolie brush stiff, mentioning that they have to use a separate one because it scratches their skin. Others found the product too expensive but added that the quality justified the price.


Best waterproof eyebrow pencil: Revlon ColorStay Brow Pencil

Pros

  • Good value for money
  • Long-lasting

Cons

  • Pencil breaks easily according to some
  • Hard to remove

Price (RRP): $11.55
Amazon pricing: From $13.69

Buy at Amazon
Buy at eBay
Buy at iHerb
Buy at Chemist Warehouse

Why we chose it

Our pick for the best waterproof eyebrow pencil is Revlon's ColorStay Brow Pencil. On Amazon, it has a rating of 4.4 out of 5 stars from 600 customer reviews.

The ColorStay Brow Pencil comes in five shades, including auburn, blonde and soft black. It features an angled tip for precise application, while the spoolie brush helps soften the colour and grooms your eyebrow hair in place. According to the company, this eyebrow pencil has a long-lasting, waterproof formula that stays on for up to 24 hours. It is also ideal for those with thin eyebrows or eyebrows with sparse areas.

Many customers loved the product's creaminess and angled tip. Customers said these features help them easily create natural-looking brows. Others praised it for being long-wearing and waterproof. They said it lasted through an intense workout session, walking in the rain and even a swim. A few customers added that the built-in spoolie brush is quite soft and makes blending the product a breeze. A few reviews mentioned that the product is hard to remove, adding a potent makeup remover is needed to completely take it off. Several customers criticised the pencil for being fragile, mentioning that it breaks off after only a couple of uses. However, this seems to be an isolated case.


Best eyebrow pencil for sparse brows: Benefit Precisely, My Brow Pencil

Pros

  • Can be used to create thicker, more defined brows
  • Comes in 12 shades

Cons

  • Not cheap
  • Bulky packaging

Price (RRP): $34.50
Amazon pricing: Check site for current pricing

Buy at Amazon
Buy at Adore Beauty
Buy at eBay
Buy at Cult Beauty

Why we chose it

If you're looking for the best eyebrow pencil for sparse brows, we recommend Benefit's Precisely, My Brow Pencil. It has a rating of 4.7 out of 5 stars from more than 600 Amazon reviews.

Benefit's Precisely, My Brow Pencil is a retractable, super-fine pencil ideal to fill in sparse brow areas for a natural look. It has a budge-proof, waterproof and 12-hour wear formula, according to the company. It also comes with a soft built-in spoolie brush for easier blending. Apart from creating hair-like strokes, the product can be used for more defined, thicker brows. It is available in a range of shades, including light blonde, warm auburn, neutral deep brown and cool soft black.

Many customers loved the pencil's ultra-fine tip, which allows for precise, hair-like strokes. Some reviews raved about how long-lasting it is, adding that it holds up even in hot and humid weather. A few customers praised the product for having a wide shade range, while others enjoyed the soft built-in spoolie. Others said it is versatile and can help create thicker brows. A few complained about the bulky packaging. Several also found the product quite expensive compared to other brow pencils in the market but said the waterproof formula is worth it.


Best eyebrow pencil for natural-looking brows: CoverGirl Easy Breezy Brow Micro-Fine Fill + Define Brow Pencil

Pros

  • Good value for money
  • Easy to remove with just soap and water

Cons

  • Only comes in 4 shades
  • Some customers found the packaging flimsy

Price (RRP): $7.92
Amazon pricing: From $8.37

Buy at Amazon
Buy at Catch
Buy at eBay
Buy at Chemist Warehouse

Why we chose it

Our pick for the best eyebrow pencil for natural-looking brows is CoverGirl's Easy Breezy Brow Micro-Fine Fill + Define Brow Pencil. On Amazon, it has a rating of 4.7 out of 5 stars from over 700 customer reviews.

This ultra-fine, retractable eyebrow pencil from CoverGirl comes in four shades. It helps create naturally defined brows that can last all day. The precise tip allows you to make hair-like strokes easily. The eyebrow pencil has a built-in spoolie brush to blend the product and groom brows. It is also suitable for sensitive eyes.

According to customers, this product is good value for money. They said the formula is creamy but doesn't budge. Others loved the ultra-fine tip, which lets them fill in sparse areas and create defined brows effortlessly. Some customers loved how long-lasting the product is while being easy to take off. They added that the product can be removed with just soap and water. However, quite a few customers criticised the shade range, saying there aren't any shades suitable for people with red or jet-black hair colours. Others found the packaging flimsy, saying that the cap breaks after just a few months of use.


Best eyebrow pencil for defined brows and sharp lines: Rimmel London Brow This Way Fill and Sculpt Eyebrow Definer

Pros

  • Long lasting
  • Can be used to create natural or more defined brows

Cons

  • Spoolie brush is stiff
  • Only comes in four shades

Price (RRP): $10.46
Amazon pricing: From $13.49

Buy at Amazon
Buy at Catch
Buy at eBay

Why we chose it

For defined brows and sharp lines, we recommend Rimmel London's Brow This Way Fill and Sculpt Eyebrow Definer as the best eyebrow pencil available in Australia right now. It has a rating of 4.4 out of 5 stars from over 2,700 customer reviews.

This eyebrow pencil has an angled tip for creating sharp lines and filling in sparse areas easily. According to the manufacturer, it features a buildable, creamy formula that is transfer-proof, fade-proof and lasts up to 12 hours. Apart from having a built-in spoolie brush, it comes in four shades – blonde, medium brown, dark brown and soft black.

According to a lot of customers, this eyebrow pencil is versatile. You can create a natural brow look or fuller, more defined brows with the pencil. Some reviews said the angled tip makes shaping their brows and creating sharp lines easy. Since the formula is creamy, the product blends seamlessly as well. Many customers also praised the eyebrow pencil's longevity, mentioning that it lasts all day. There were complaints about the shade range, with a few customers adding that they couldn't find an accurate shade match. Others also found the built-in spoolie stiff, making it hard to groom their brows in place but this seems to be a minor concern.


Amazon prices last updated on 23 June, 2021 at 01:01 pm

Methodology

28
Brands considered
63
Products compared
7
Best products chosen
  • We compared eyebrow pencils from 28 brands and over 60 products.
  • We then assessed hundreds of customer reviews and ratings from Amazon customers (as of January 2021).
  • The products on this list are chosen by our editorial team and are not selected based on commercial relationships.

More guides on Finder

Ask an Expert

You are about to post a question on finder.com.au:

  • Do not enter personal information (eg. surname, phone number, bank details) as your question will be made public
  • finder.com.au is a financial comparison and information service, not a bank or product provider
  • We cannot provide you with personal advice or recommendations
  • Your answer might already be waiting – check previous questions below to see if yours has already been asked

Finder only provides general advice and factual information, so consider your own circumstances, or seek advice before you decide to act on our content. By submitting a question, you're accepting our Terms of Use, Disclaimer & Privacy Policy and Privacy & Cookies Policy.
Go to site