23andMe vs AncestryDNA: How do these DNA tests compare? | Finder

23andMe vs AncestryDNA

Which DNA test provides the most comprehensive results for your needs?

Updated

Fact checked

We’re reader-supported and may be paid when you visit links to partner sites. We don’t compare all products in the market, but we’re working on it!

DNA tests are done for a whole range of personal and medical reasons. Whatever it is you're seeking to find out, it's a good idea to compare a few different DNA testing companies before settling on the kit that works for you.

In this article, we help you make the right choice by comparing the key features of 23andMe and AncestryDNA.

23andMe and AncestryDNA: How do the brands compare?

23andMe logo

23andMe

AncestryDNA logo

AncestryDNA

DescriptionGet details of genetic health risks and find unknown relatives from around the globe.Find out more about your family's origins and learn about yourself.
DNA collection typeSalivaSaliva
Test typemtDNA
Y-DNA
Autosomal
Autosomal
Result in6-8 weeks6-8 weeks
Price per kitFrom $145 (excludes shipping)From $129 (excludes shipping)
Database size10 million18 million
DNA matching?YesYes
Genetic traits report?YesYes
Ancestry reportsYesYes
Geographic regions2,000 +1,100 +
Downloadable raw data?YesYes
Family tree softwareYesYes

Collection method

Both 23andMe and AncestryDNA provide clients with a test tube to collect their saliva to process their DNA. The collection method is relatively easy as all you will have to do is spit into the test tube, ensure the cap is secure and then ship it out to the company.

Testing

AncestryDNA tests your autosomal DNA to cover your family tree's maternal and paternal sides. 23andMe also uses autosomal testing, but it can also estimate your y-DNA and mtDNA haplogroups. This information could help you to trace your ancestry more widely.

Ethnic regions

The results you receive will depend on the package you choose, how detailed the company is and the number of regions it covers.

AncestryDNA covers more than 1,100 regions including ethnicities from Cameroon, Congo and Western Bantu Peoples, Early North Carolina African Americans, Northern Philippines and more. The brand compares your DNA to the DNA of people with known origins from around the world, known as its reference panel. AncestryDNA has a total of 44,703 DNA samples. However, the current AncestryDNA genetic ethnicity does not provide a direct estimate of Aboriginal Australian Ethnicity.

In comparison, 23andMe covers more than 2,000 regions worldwide. These regions are European, East Asian, Native American, West Asian, North African, Sub-Saharan African, Melanesian and recent ancestry in the Americas.

Results

With AncestryDNA, you can break down your ethnicity by percentage and determine the degree of relatedness you may have to another person. AncestryDNA offers ThruLines, which show you the common ancestors which are likely connecting you to your DNA matches. The company also predicts your traits and provides health and wellness reports.

23andMe provides reports on your ancestry timeline and inherited traits and detailed insights into your personalised characteristics and features. Some examples are the ability to match musical pitch, cleft chin, earlobe type, cilantro taste aversion, ice cream flavour preference and more. Perhaps more importantly, it provides information on genetic health risks and carrier status. It also has an optional online network, DNA Relative Finder, where you can find matches, compare ancestries and traits.

Additionally, 23andMe will automatically build a family tree from your DNA relationships.

Processing speed

The processing speed of both Ancestry DNA and 23andMe typically takes six to eight weeks. Once your results are ready, log on to the specific web portal to view the report to view your results. Ancestry DNA will email you a notification when your information is prepared to be viewed.

Price

23andMe offers different services starting at $139 before shipping. If you're looking for a premium kit, you can pay more for its Health and Ancestry service or the VIP Health and Ancestry service.

AncestryDNA's kit is $129 and an additional cost for shipping. The company also offers memberships starting at $21.99. Becoming a member may give you access to records of different regions as well as the ability to connect with other Ancestry members. Membership typically gives you access to records on birth, marriage, death, census, military, church and more.

Privacy and security

Both 23andMe and AncestryDNA identify the samples only with a unique code to track your DNA. Results are encrypted and stored in a secured database to protect the information from unauthorised access.

The company sets internal limitations on accessing the database. If you agree to AncestryDNA’s Informed Consent for Research, the company will store your sample for future research; otherwise, you can choose to have your sample destroyed.

23andMe requires clients to review its Consent Document for Sample Storage and Additional Genetic Analyses during the kit registration. Unless clients consent to Biobanking or sample storage, the saliva sample and DNA are destroyed after the laboratory completes its work.

Verdict

One of AncestryDNA's key features is the provision of the ethnic breakdown of your DNA through an interactive map. While it is possible to peruse historical documents with AncestryDNA, this feature is limited to the US and UK record collections only.

Given its similar price point, we'd say therefore that 23andMe has the edge on its close rival. 23andMe offers a more robust view of health information, in our view. Additionally, it includes some exciting factors like traits on back hair and Neanderthal heritage. 23andMe also offers a broader region with over 2,000 areas worldwide.

Compare more DNA test kits

Data updated regularly
Name Product DNA Collection Type Test Type Result in Price per kit
AncestryDNA
Saliva
Autosomal
6-8 weeks
From $129
Learn about your family's health and origins with over 1,100 regions analysed.
Living DNA
Cheek swab
atDNA, mtDNA, Y-DNA
6-8 weeks
From $139
Receive ancestry reports with actionable insights about your health with results.
23andMe
Saliva
mtDNA, Y-DNA, Autosomal
6-8 weeks
From $145
Get details of genetic health risks and find unknown relatives from across the globe.
MyHeritage DNA
Cheek swab
Autosomal
3-4 weeks
From $139 (plus shipping)
Personalised & comprehensive assistance in 19+ languages all over the world.
Findmypast
Findmypast
Cheek swab
atDNA, mtDNA, Y-DNA
6 - 8 weeks
From $129
Find out if you have a British or Irish past and trace your history with records dating back to 1538.
loading

Compare up to 4 providers

Frequently asked questions

Why do some DNA samples fail?

If a test tube’s cap is not secure, the lab might not have enough of your saliva to process. Typically, you should also not eat, drink, smoke, chew gum, brush your teeth or use mouthwash for at least 30 minutes before providing a sample.

Can I do a DNA test if I've had a bone marrow transplant?

Generally, people who have received a bone marrow should get a close relative, like a parent or sibling, tested instead. Since your cells will contain blood cells created by the bone marrow, your saliva will probably include your DNA and that of your bone marrow donor. So, your results can end up inconclusive or possibly report the results of your donor.

How long is a DNA kit good for?

Many companies have an end-date saliva collection printed on the test tube. Generally speaking, you can store a DNA kit for at least a year after the date of purchase. But be sure to check the manufacturer's guidance on any DNA test you're looking to buy.

More guides on Finder

  • Living DNA vs 23andMe

    Choose between two leading DNA testing companies who can help you map your ancestry and genetics.

  • MyHeritage vs 23andMe

    Discover the main differences between two leading DNA testing services, from pricing to privacy.

  • AncestryDNA vs MyHeritage

    Understand the key points of difference between these two leading DNA testing services.

  • Prime Day Deal: AncestryDNA test kits for $99 ($60 off)

    AncestryDNA's popular DNA testing kits are currently selling for $99 on Amazon. That's $60 off the RRP.

  • Living DNA Review

    Compare four Living DNA test kits, including their key features and costs in our guide.

  • 23andMe review

    23andMe is a DNA testing kit that helps you understand your ethnicity, pinpoint medical risks and find distant relatives.

  • MyHeritage Review

    What you need to know about MyHeritage's no-frills DNA kits, which offer competitively-priced tests and fast results.

  • AncestryDNA Review

    Whether you're looking to find a long-lost relative or just learn about your family's past, AncestryDNA could meet your needs.

  • Cash Converters vs MoneyMe

    Finding the right short term loan is important, and comparing your options is the first step towards doing so. We compare the fees, rates and features of Cash Converters and MoneyMe to help you decide.

  • Wallet Wizard vs MoneyMe

    Finding the right short-term lender is an important step to ensuring your loan is affordable. We compare two prominent short-term lenders, Wallet Wizard and MoneyMe, to help you find the best loan for you.

Ask an Expert

You are about to post a question on finder.com.au:

  • Do not enter personal information (eg. surname, phone number, bank details) as your question will be made public
  • finder.com.au is a financial comparison and information service, not a bank or product provider
  • We cannot provide you with personal advice or recommendations
  • Your answer might already be waiting – check previous questions below to see if yours has already been asked

Finder only provides general advice and factual information, so consider your own circumstances, or seek advice before you decide to act on our content. By submitting a question, you're accepting our Terms of Use, Disclaimer & Privacy Policy and Privacy & Cookies Policy.
Go to site